Evaluation of error types seen in digital panoramic radiographs

Year 2024, , 73 - 78, 19.09.2024

Bahar Kaplan , Ezgi Katı

https://doi.org/10.70509/dicledentj.1519676

Abstract

Aims: This study aimed to assess the prevalence of different types of errors in panoramic radiography and explore potential correlations between these errors, age, and gender.
Methods: A total of 2000 panoramic radiographs randomly selected from the patient archives of the Department of Oral, Dental, and Maxillofacial Radiology at Dicle University Faculty of Dentistry, taken in 2023 for various indications, were analyzed. Two experienced radiologists (BK and EK) reviewed the digital panoramic X-ray images. Interobserver agreement was assessed by having both observers re-evaluate 10% of the sample. Patients with developmental anomalies, history of trauma, orthognathic surgery, maxillofacial pathology (e.g., tumors/cysts), and those under 16 years old were excluded. Statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS 20.0 software (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA), with a significance level set at α=5%. Cohen’s kappa statistics were utilized to calculate intraobserver agreement.
Results: In the analysis of 2000 panoramic radiographs, it was found that 81.16% exhibited at least one error. The predominant error identified was the misplacement of the tongue against the palate, accounting for 34.75% of cases. A statistically significant association was observed between increasing patient age and higher error rates (p<0.05). However, no significant correlation was found between gender and error occurrence (p>0.05).
Conclusion: The prevalence of positioning errors in panoramic radiography is considerable. It underscores the importance of providing adequate training to healthcare professionals and technicians to mitigate the risk of misinterpretation and unnecessary exposure to radiation.

Keywords

Patient positioning, diagnostic errors, panoramic radiography

Ethical Statement

This research was authorized by the Dicle University Faculty of Dentistry's ethics committee under the protocol number 2023-03. The present study was carried out in accordance with the principles delineated in the Declaration of Helsinki, as revised in 2008.

Thanks

We would like to extend our appreciation to Associate Professor Merve Yeniçeri Özata for her contributions to the statistical evaluation of the article.

References

• Kattimani S, Kempwade P, Ramesh D, Byatnal A, Nasreen S, Subashani T. Determination of different positioning errors in digital panoramic radiography: a retrospective study. J Med Radiol Pathol Surg. 2019;6(2):5-8.
• Scott AM, Reed WM. Panoramic radiography and patients with disability: a new simple breathing technique to reduce common airspace error. Wiley Online Library; 2022.
• Koç N, Özbek Ş. Panoramik Radyografi. Ankara Diş Hekimleri Odası; 2021. p.75-76.
• Sadr S, Mohammad-Rahimi H, Ghorbanimehr MS, Rokhshad R, Abbasi Z, Soltani P, et al. Deep learning for tooth identification and enumeration in panoramic radiographs. Dent Res J. 2023; 20(1):116-118.
• Glass BJ. Successful panoramic radiography: Eastman Kodak Company, Health Imaging, Dental; 2000.
• Pawar RR, Makdissi J. The role of focal block (trough/plane) in panoramic radiography: Why do some structures appear blurred out on these images? Radiography. 2014;20(2):167-70.
• Kumar N. Assessment of common errors and subjective quality of digital panoramic radiographs in a dental institution. Dent Med Res. 2020;8(1):23-26.
• Belgin CA, Serindere G. Evaluation of error types and quality on panoramic radiography. Int Dent Res. 2019;9(3):99-104.
• Subbulakshmi AC, Mohan N, Thiruneervannan R, Naveen S, Gokulraj S. Positioning errors in digital panoramic radiographs: a study. J Orofac Sci. 2016;8(1):22-26.
• Hacıosmanoğlu N, Eren H, Küçükkalem MF, Görgün S. Dijital panoramik radyograflarda çekim sırasında yapılan hatalar. Selcuk Dent J. 2019;6(4):209-215.
• Khator AM, Motwani MB, Choudhary AB. A study for determination of various positioning errors in digital panoramic radiography for evaluation of diagnostic image quality. Indian J Dent Res. 2017;28(6):666-670.
• Lingam AS, Koppolu P, Abdulsalam R, Reddy RL, Anwarullah A, Koppolu D. Assessment of common errors and subjective quality of digital panoramic radiographs in dental institution, Riyadh. Ann Afr Med. 2023;22(1):49-54.
• Fux-Noy A, Rohana R, Rettman A, Moskovitz M, Nadler C. Panoramic errors in pediatric patients with special needs. Scientific Rep. 2023;13(1):11757.
• Trader E, Joshi A, Gurupur V, editors. Landmark Facial Feature Detection to Reduce Positioning Error in Panoramic X-Rays. 2024 IEEE International Conference on Electro Information Technology (eIT); 2024: IEEE.
• Marsha EA, Kiswanjaya B, Bachtiar-Iskandar HH. Comparison of positioning errors on panoramic radiographs in Indonesian children, adults, and elderly patients. J Stomatol. 2023;76(1):175-181.
• Asriningrum S, Sudrajat I, Meliawati M. Technical error factors on panoramic radiographic examination at the radiology installation of Unjani Dental and Mouth Hospital. Int J Business Eco Soc Develop. 2023;4(4):279-286.
• Dhillon M, Raju SM, Verma S, et al. Positioning errors and quality assessment in panoramic radiography. Imag Sci Dent. 2012;42(4): 207-212.
• Izzetti R, Nisi M, Aringhieri G, Crocetti L, Graziani F, Nardi C. Basic knowledge and new advances in panoramic radiography imaging techniques: a narrative review on what dentists and radiologists should know. Applied Sci. 2021;11(17):7858.
• Suparno NR, Faizah A, Nafisah AN. Assessment of panoramic radiograph errors: an evaluation of patient preparation and positioning quality at soelastri dental and oral hospital. Open Dent J. 2023;17(1):1-9.
• Khan SQ, Ashraf B, Mehdi H. Evaluation of patient preparation and positioning errors on digital panoramic radiographs. Pakistan Oral Dent J. 2015;35(1):65-69.
• Pfeiffer P, Bewersdorf S, Schmage P. The effect of changes in head position on enlargement of structures during panoramic radiography. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 2012;27(1):55-63.
• Rondon RHN, Pereira YCL, do Nascimento GC. Common positioning errors in panoramic radiography: a review. Imag Sci Dent. 2014;44(1):1-6.
• Bagherpour A, Moshtagh-Khorasani I, Safaee A. Common positioning errors in digital panoramic radiographies taken in Mashhad Dental School. J Dent Mater Techniq. 2018;7(2):89-96.
• Akarslan ZZ, Erten H, Güngör K, Çelik L. Common errors on panoramic radiographs taken in a dental school. J Contemp Dent Pract. 2005;4(2):24-34.
• Costa ED, Cral WG, Murad FP, Oliveira M, Ambrosano G, Freitas D. Prevalence of errors and number of retakes in panoramic radiography: influence of professional training and patient characteristics. Int J Odontostomat (Internet). 2021;15(3):719-726.
• Singh S, Singh I, Ahmed F, Baba A. Retrospective study: evaluating the positioning errors in digital panoramic radiographs. Indian J Contemp Dent. 2022;10(2):5-8.
• Mayil M, Keser G, Pekiner FN. Clinical image quality assessment in panoramic radiography. Clin Exp Health Sci. 2014;4(3):126-132.