Contrasting Democratic Trajectories: A Comparative Analysis of Costa Rica and Nicaragua

Year 2024, Volume: 11 Issue: 3, 1113 - 1135, 30.09.2024

Önder Aytaç Afşar , Karina Veronica Val Sanchez

https://doi.org/10.30798/makuiibf.1461753

Abstract

The main focus of this paper is the democracy process in Central America. It is a case study focuses on Costa Rica and Nicaragua and its respective trajectories towards democracy. Despite their shared historical backgrounds, culture, similar size, and geographical location, Costa Rica has one of the most peaceful and enduring democracies, while Nicaragua has been a tumultuous country with internal conflicts that have directly impacted its democratization. The historical context of colonial exploitation, socio-economic disparities, and political unrest has significantly shaped the contemporary political landscape of the region. This research uses Costa Rica and Nicaragua as examples to highlight the diverse paths of democratic development in Central America. Since 1948, Costa Rica has been a democratic country, while Nicaragua has undergone a dual transition, one through revolution (1984) and the other through democratic elections in 1990. By emphasizing the unique historical peculiarities of the region, valuable insights into the democratization processes are provided. The study uses a historical method to analyze the democratization processes in Costa Rica and Nicaragua. It examines the impact of the conquest period, the role of key factors such as landed oligarchies and military forces, the influence of international economic crises, and the current democratic quality in both countries. The study shows that historical legacies have lasting effects on democracy.

Keywords

Central America, Democratization., democracy

References

• Altman, D., & Pérez-Liñán, A. (2002). Assessing the quality of democracy: freedom, competitiveness and participation in eighteen Latin American countries. Democratization, 9(2), 85-100.
• Baloyra-Herp, E. A. (1983). Reactionary despotism in Central America. Journal of Latin American Studies, 15(2), 295-319. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022216X00000730
• Barreda, M. (2011). La calidad de la democracia: Un análisis comparado de América Latina. Política y Gobierno, 18(2), 265-295.
• Bermeo, N., & Yashar, D. J. (2016). Parties, movements, and democracy in the developing world. Cambridge University Press.
• Blachman, M. J., & Sharpe, K. E. (2019). The transitions to “electoral” and democratic politics in Central America: Assessing the role of political parties. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America (pp.33-52). Routledge.
• Booth, J. A. (2000). Costa Rica: Buffeted democracy. In Walker, T. W., & Armony, A. C., (Eds.) Repression, resistance, and democratic transition in Central America (pp. 89-110). Rowman & Littlefield.
• Booth, J. A., & Richard, P. B. (2006). Revolution's legacy: Residual effects on Nicaraguan participation and attitudes in comparative context. Latin American Politics and Society, 48(2), 117-140.
• Booth, J. A., Wade, C. J., & Walker, T. W. (2010). Understanding Central America: Global forces and political change (5th ed.). Routledge.
• Booth, J. A., Wade, C. J., & Walker, T. W. (2020). Understanding Central America: Global forces and political change (7th ed.). Routledge.
• Breuer, A. (2007). Institutions of direct democracy and accountability in Latin America's presidential democracies. Democratization, 14(4), 554-579. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510340701398287
• Brockett, C. D. (2019). Land, power, and poverty: Agrarian transformation and political conflict in Central America. Routledge.
• Capoccia, G. (2016). Critical Junctures. In O. Fioretos, T. G. Falleti, & A. Sheingate (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism (pp. 89-106). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199662814.013.5
• Capoccia, G., & Ziblatt, D. (2010). The historical turn in democratization studies: A new research agenda for Europe and beyond. Comparative Political Studies, 43(8-9), 931-968. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414010370431
• Cerdas Cruz, R. (2019). Colonial Heritage, External Domination, and Political Systems in Central America. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America. Routledge.
• Chavez, J. M. (2022). The Cold War: Authoritarianism, Empire, and Social Revolution. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 335–358). Oxford University Press.
• Charlip, J. (2022). Nicaragua. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 567-590). Oxford University Press.
• Corbetta, J., & Pérez-Liñán, A. (2001). Calidad de la democracia: Un análisis de la trayectoria argentina. Instituciones y Desarrollo, 10(3), 149-169.
• Dahl, R. A. (1971). Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition. Yale University Press. Diamond, L., & Morlino, L. (2004). The quality of democracy: An overview. Journal of Democracy, 15(4), pp. 20-31. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2004.0060
• Frances, H., & Alegria, C. (1983). The war of terror against Nicaragua. The Black Scholar, 14(2), 2-16. Freedom House. (2023a, January 12). Costa Rica. https://freedomhouse.org/country/costa-rica/freedom-world/2023
• Freedom House. (2023b, January 12). Nicaragua. https://freedomhouse.org/country/nicaragua/freedom-world/2023#PR
• Gobat, M. (2022). Central America and the United States. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 309-334). Oxford University Press.
• Godoy Reyes, V. (2019). Nicaragua 1944-84: Political parties and electoral processes. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America. Routledge.
• Goodman, L. (2019). Political parties and the political systems of Central America. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America. Routledge.
• Goodman, L. W., LeoGrande, W. M., Forman, J. M., & Sharpe, K. (2019). Political parties and democracy in Central America. Routledge.
• Guevara, E. (2023a). Costa Rica 2022: Una alternancia política en medio de una crisis partidista. Les études du CERI, 264-265, 54-56.
• Guevara, T. (2023, Dec 5). Presidente de Costa Rica denuncia penalmente al diario La Nación por difundir audios “confidenciales”. Voz de America. https://www.vozdeamerica.com/a/presidente-chaves-denuncia-penalmente-a-la-naci%C3%B3n-en-costa-rica-por-difundir-audios-confidenciales/7385544.html
• Harrison, L. E. (1984). US Economic Aid Policy in Central America. The Fletcher Forum, 8(1), 33-44. Human Rights Watch. (2023, 2023a, January 13). Nicaragua. https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2024/country-chapters/nicaragua
• Jeffrey L., G. (2014). Indigenista dictators and the problematic origins of democracy in Central America. In P. Drinot & A. Knight (Eds.), The Great Depression in Latin America (pp. 188-212). Duke University Press.
• Klak, T. (2014). Globalization, neoliberalism and economic change in Central America and the Caribbean. In R. N. Gwynne & K. Cristobal (Eds.), Latin America Transformed: Globalization and Modernity (pp. 67-92). Routledge.
• Latinobarómetro. (2020, March). Encuesta de Opinión Pública de América Latina. https://www.latinobarometro.org/latOnline.jsp
• Latinobarómetro. (2023, July 21). Encuesta de Opinión Pública de América Latina. https://www.latinobarometro.org/latOnline.jsp
• LeoGrande, W. M. (2019). Political parties and postrevolutionary politics in Nicaragua. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America (pp. 164-174). Routledge.
• Levine, D. H., & Molina, J. E. (2007). La calidad de la democracia en América Latina: una visión comparada. América Latina Hoy, 45, 17-46.
• Mahoney, J. (2001). The legacies of liberalism: Path dependence and political regimes in Central America. The JHU Press.
• Mahoney, J. (2001). Path-dependent explanations of regime change: Central America in comparative perspective. Studies in comparative international development, 36, 111-141. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02687587
• Mahoney, J., & Snyder, R. (1999). Rethinking agency and structure in the study of regime change. Studies in Comparative International Development, 34, 3-32. https://doi.org/doi.org/10.1007/BF02687620
• Mainwaring, S. (2003). Introduction: Democratic accountability in Latin America. In S. Mainwaring & C. Welna (Eds.), Democratic Accountability in Latin America (pp. 3-33). Oxford University Press.
• Marini, R. M., & Sader, E. (1991). Dialéctica de la dependencia. Era México Martí, I. P., Rodríguez-Suárez, D., & Serra, M. (2022). Nicaragua 2020-2022: el cierre autoritario. Revista de ciencia política (Santiago), 42(2), 383-406. Martí, I. P., & Serra, M. (2020). Nicaragua: De-democratization and regime crisis. Latin American Politics and Society, 62(2), 117-136. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1017/lap.2019.64
• Matthew, L. E. (2022). The Spanish Conquest? In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 141-166). Oxford University Press.
• Millett, R. L. (2019). Politicized Warriors: The military and Central American politics. In L. W. Goodman, W. M. LeoGrande, J. M. Forman, & K. Sharpe (Eds.), Political Parties and Democracy in Central America. Routledge.
• Møller, J. (2012). When one might not see the wood for the trees: the ‘historical turn’ in democratization studies, critical junctures, and cross-case comparisons. Democratization, 20(4), 693–715. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2012.659023
• Møller, J., & Skaaning, S. E. (2012). Democracy and Democratization in Comparative Perspective: Conceptions, Conjunctures, Causes, and Consequences (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203083994
• Molina, I. (2022). Costa Rica. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 591-614). Oxford University Press.
• Moore, B. (1993). Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: Lord and peasant in the making of the modern world. Beacon Press.
• Morlino, L. (2014). La calidad de las democracias en América Latina: informe para IDEA. The International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance.
• Munck, G. L. (2023). The state as a determinant of democracy: durable poor-quality democracies in contemporary Latin America. Democratization, 1-25. https://doi.org/doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2023.2267992
• Munro, D. G. (1933). The Establishment of Peace in Nicaragua. Foreign Affairs, 11(4), pp. 696-705. https://doi.org/10.2307/20030547
• O’Donnell. (2001). Democracy, law, and comparative politics. Studies in comparative international development, 36, 7-36. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02687583
• Paige, J. M. (2005). Coffee, revolution, and democracy in Central America. In P. S. Ciccantell, Smith, D.A. and Seidman, G (Ed.), Nature, Raw Materials, and Political Economy (pp. 333-352). Emerald Group Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1057-1922(05)10015-8
• Perez, O., & Pestana, R. (2022). The rise and retreat of the armed forces. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 379-402). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199811755.001.0001
• Petras, J., & Zeitlin, M. (1969). Latin America: Reform or Revolution? Science and Society, 33(1), 90-96. Powell Jr., G. B. (2004). The chain of responsiveness. Journal of Democracy, 15(4), 91-105. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2004.0070
• Quijano, A., Gutiérrez, G., López, S., & Wallerstein, I. (1980). Los usos de la democracia burguesa. Sociedad y Política (10), 7-15.
• Redondo, A. R. (2023). Elecciones 2022 en Costa Rica: resultado sorpresivo que no altera las frágiles condiciones para gobernar. Revista Uruguaya de Ciencia Política, 32(1), 169-187. https://doi.org/10.26851/rucp.32.1.8
• Robinson, W. I. (2003). Transnational conflicts: Central America, social change, and globalization. Verso. Rojas Bolaños, M. (1995). Consolidar la democracia en Centroamérica: una ardua tarea. In K. Tangermann (Ed.), Ilusiones y dilemas. La democracia en Centroamérica (pp. 99-156). FLACSO.
• Schedler, A., Diamond, L. J., & Plattner, M. F. (1999). The Self-Restraining State: Power And Accountability in New Democracies. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
• Stone, S. Z., & Greenleaf, R. E. (1990). The heritage of the conquistadors: Ruling classes in Central America from the conquest to the Sandinistas. University of Nebraska Press Lincoln.
• Tilly, C. (2017). From Mobilization to Revolution. In E. Castañeda & C. Schneider (Eds.), Collective Violence, Contentious Politics, and Social Change (pp. 39–100). https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315205021
• The International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. (2024). Costa Rica https://www.idea.int/data-tools/country-overview?country=54
• The International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. (2024). Nicaragua https://www.idea.int/data-tools/country-overview?country=161
• The World Bank. (2019, January 14). Strength of legal rights index https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IC.LGL.CRED.XQ?locations=NI-CR-1W&view=chart
• The World Bank. (2021, January 12). Intentional homicides (per 100,000 people) - Nicaragua, Costa Rica. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/VC.IHR.PSRC.P5?end=2021&locations=NI-CR&start=1990&view=char
• Transparency International. (2022a, January 14). Costa Rica. https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/costa-rica
• Transparency International. (2022b, January 14). Nicaragua. https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/nicaragua
• Vilas, C. (2000). Neoliberalism in Central America. In J. A. Booth (Ed.), Repression, Resistance, and Democratic Transition in Central America (pp. 211-232). Rowman & Littlefield.
• Walker, T. W., & Armony, A. C. (2000). Repression, Resistance, and Democratic Transition in Central America. Rowman & Littlefield.
• Whitehead, L., Schmitter, P. C., & O'Donnell, G. (2013). Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Latin America. Johns Hopkins University Press.
• Williams, R. G. (2022). The Political Economy. In R. Holden (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Central American History (pp. 253-284). Oxford University Press.