Körfez’de Kültür Politikasının Gelişimini Anlamak: Doha ve Dubai Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme

Year 2024, Volume: 14, 61 - 78, 30.06.2024

Oytun Doğan

https://doi.org/10.13114/mjh.1429819

Abstract

Kültür politikaları, kültürün sadece sanat yönetimi açısından yorumlanmadığı gelişme, üretim ve pazarlama açısından ele alındığı bir alan olmuştur. Kültür politikaları kent kimliğine bağlı olduğu gibi ekonomiye ilişkin politikaları da oluşturmuştur. Bu araştırma küreselliğe yönelik olarak gelişen kültür politikalarını Doha ve Dubai örneklemi üzerinden değerlendirilmeyi amaçlamıştır. Bunun sebebi yeraltı yatırımlarından kaynaklı servete sahip ve nüfus yoğunluğu az olan bu kentlerin kültür politikalarını incelemektir. Ayrıca bölgenin en fazla turist çeken destinasyonları ve en çok turizm harcamasının yapıldığı kentler olması örneklem seçiminde etkili olmuştur. Bu değerlendirmede Dubaileşme ve Dohalaşma olarak iki kavram kullanılmış ve kültür politikalarının bu açıdan ele alınması amaçlanmıştır. Araştırma evreninin bu kentler özelinde seçiminde bölge üzerine hazırlanmış akademik araştırmalar nitel açıdan yorumlanmıştır. Literatür taraması kültür politikalarının sanat ve müzeler aracılığıyla incelenmesiyle sınırlandırılmıştır. İnceleme kültür politikası kavramının örneklem üzerinden değerlendirilmesidir.

Keywords

sanat, müze, kültür politikaları, Doha, Dubai

References

• Abdessamad F. 2023, We need to push back at art from the West': The Gulf as a cultural hub, Kaynak: https://www.middleeasteye.net/discover/arab-gulf-drive-become-hub-culture-museums-art.
• Adhan K. 2008, “Rediscovering the Island: Doha’s Urbanity from Pearls to Spectacle”. Ed. Yasser Elsheshtawy, The Evolving Arab City: Tradition, Modernity and Urban Development. London, 218-257.
• Ahmed F. B. J. 2019, “Foreign Universities in Qatar: A Critical Review of Policy and Sustainability Issues”. Challenges of the Knowledge Society, 13, 50-59.
• Ali S. 2010, Dubai Gilded Cage. London.
• Al-Maria S. 2012, The Girl Who Fell to Earth. New York.
• Alraouf A. A. 2016, “‘Dohaization’: An Emerging Interface between Knowledge, Creativity, and Gulf Urbanity”. Eds. George Katodrytis and Sharmeen Syed, Gulf Cities as Interfaces. Cambridge, 47-68.
• Alraouf A. A. 2016, “One nation, one myth and two museums Heritage, architecture and culture as tools for assembling identity in Qatar”. Eds. Pamela Erskine-Loftus, Mariam Al-Mulla and Victoria Hightower, Representing the Nation Heritage, museums, national narratives and identity in the Arab Gulf States. London, 79-94.
• Alraouf A. A. 2020, “Beyond Oil: The Inevitability of Knowledge-Based Urbanism in Middle Eastern and Gulf Cities”. Review of World Planning Practice, 16, 21-38.
• Anon 2012, Years of Culture Qatar. Kaynak: https://yearsofculture.qa/about.
• Anon 2014, BBC News. Kaynak: https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-30001716.
• Appleyard C. & Salzmann J. 2012, Corporate Art Collections: A Handbook to Corporate Buying. Farnham.
• Baysal C. U. 2016, “Kabataş Martı Projesi: İstanbul’un Dubaileştirilmesi ve Mimarinin Etiği”. mimar.ist, 57, 14-17.
• Beblawi H. 2016, The Concept of “Rentier States” Revisited. Eds. Ahmed Galal and Ishac Diwan, The Middle East Economies in Times of Transition. London, 199-212.
• Bell D. & Oakley K. 2015, Cultural Policy. New York.
• Bendixen P. 1994, “Cultural Policy and the Aesthetics of Industrialism”. Cultural Policy, 1/1, 121-139. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286639409357974.
• Biln J. & El-Amrousi M. 2014. “Dubai’s Heritage House Museums: A Semiosis of Melancholy”. Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Revies, 25/2, 23-38.
• BrandFinance 2024, Global Soft Power Index 2023. Kaynak: https://brandirectory.com/softpower/ ranking?region=1&metric=8&statement=0.
• Çağrıcı M. 1991, “Asabiyet”. Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı İslam Ansiklopedisi, 3, 453-455.
• Carbonell A. 2016, “Dubai: The Political Project of a New Metropolis”. Eds. George Katodrytis and Sharmeen Syed, Gulf Cities as Interfaces. Cambridge, 229-242.
• Curtis S. 2011, “Global cities and the transformation of the International System”. Review of International Studies, 37/4, 1923-1947.
• Davidson C. M. 1988, Abu Dhabi Oil and Beyond. London.
• Dawson A. 2018, Jameel Arts Centre: Dubai gets first non-governmental contemporary art space, Kaynak:https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2018/11/12/jameel-arts-centre-dubai-gets-first-non-governmental-contemporary-art-space.
• Doğan O. 2022, Orta Doğuda Küreselleşme ve Kimlik Ekseninde Müzecilik: Katar İslam Sanatları Müzesi ve Modern Arap Sanatları Müzesi Örnekleri. Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi, Marmara Üniversitesi. İstanbul.
• Dubai Cultur. 2021, 2021 Annual Report, Kaynak: https://dubaiculture.gov.ae/-/media/DC/Annual-Reports/DC-2021-Annual-Report---
• Dubai Culture. 2023, Who We Are Curating Culture. Kaynak: https://dubaiculture.gov.ae/en/about-us/who-we-are.
• Dubai Culture. 2023, Promoting Dubai’s cultural landscape. Kaynak: https://dubaiculture.gov.ae/en/about-us/Strategy.
• Dubai Future Foundation. 2023, Museum of The Future Showcasing a New Era. Kaynak: https://www.dubaifuture.ae/initiatives/future-experience/museum-of-the-future.
• Dubai Knowledge. 2023, Dubai Higher Education. Kaynak: https://web.khda.gov.ae/en/Education-Directory/Higher-Education.
• Elsheshtawy, Y. 2008, Cities of Sand and Fog: Abu Dhabi’s Arrival on the Global Scene. Ed. Yasser Elsheshtawy, The Evolving Arab City Tradition, Modernity and Urban Development. London, 258-304.
• Er Y. 2017, Klasik Arkeoloji Sözlüğü. Ankara.
• Excell K. 2016, Modernity and the Museum in the Arabian Peninsula. New York.
• Exell K. 2014, “Collecting an Alternative World: The Sheikh Faisal bin Qassim Al Thani Museum in Qatar”. Eds. K. Exell and T. Rico, Cultural Heritage in the Arabian Peninsula. Burlington, 51-70.
• Exell K. 2017, “Doha’s cultural armature on display: a response to Artifacts and Allegiances: How Museums put the Nation and the World on Display”. Identities, 24/1, 19-25. https://doi.org/10.1080/1070289X.2016.1260018
• Fernandes F. 2023, Ranked: Top 10 Cities Where International Travelers Spend the Most. Kaynak: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/ranked-top-10-cities-where-international-travelers-spend-the-most/
• Frangos M. 2017, “The Girl Who Fell to Earth: Sophia Al-Maria’s Retro-Futurism”. C21 Literature: Journal of 21st-century Writings, 5/3, 1-21.
• Fromherz A. J. 2012, Qatar A Modern History. Washington.
• Fuccaro N. 2009, Histories of City and State in the Persian Gulf. Cambrdige.
• Golasz-Szolomicka H. & Szolomicki J. 2020, “Selected Modern Public Culture and Educational Buildings in Countries of the Persian Gulf”, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 960, 1-10. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1757-899X/960/2/022052.
• Gold J. R. 2019, “The Modern City”. Eds. Rob Kitchin and Nigel Thrift, International Encyclopedia of Human Geography. Oxford, 150-156.
• Graebner S. 2014, “The Louvre Abu Dhabi: French Universalism, Exported”, L'Esprit Créateur, 54/2, 186-199. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26378905.
• Hamnett C. & Shoval N. 2003, “Museums as Flagships of Urban Development”. Eds. Lily M. Hoffman, Susan S. Fainstein and Dennis R. Judd, Cities and visitors: regulating people, markets, and city space. Malden, 219-236.
• Hansen T. B. 1995, “Measuring the value of culture”. The European Journal of Cultural Policy, 1/2, 309-322. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286639509357988.
• Jarry R. 2024, Art Dubai 2024: Platforming the Global South from the Arabian Gulf, Kaynak: https://www.stirworld.com/think-opinions-art-dubai-2024-platforming-the-global-south-from-the-arabian-gulf. Jusdanis G. 2022, Gecikmiş Modernlik ve Estetik Kültür. Çev: T. Birkan, İstanbul.
• Kakar A. 2024, Art Dubai Highlights the City’s Growing Appeal with Asian Collectors, Kaynak: https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-art-dubai-highlights-citys-growing-appeal-asian-collectors.
• Karvelyte K. 2018, “From arts desert to global cultural metropolis The (re)branding of Shanghai and Hong Kong”. Eds. V. Durrer, T. Miller and D. O’Brien, The Routledge Handbook of Global Cultural Policy. New York, 247-264.
• Kawashima N. 1997, “Theorising decentralisation in cultural policy: Concepts, values and strategies”. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 3/2, 341-359. DOI: 10.1080/10286639709358053.
• Kinzel M. & Tanaka M. 2015, Imagining the Past Visitor specific applications for Al Zubarah Archaeological Site, Qatar. Kaynak: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7419608.
• Kluijver R. 2013, Contemporary Art in the Gulf Context and Perspectives. Kaynak: https://robertk.space/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Contemporary-Art-in-the-Gulf-for-print.pdf.
• Köşker N. 2018, “Mekan ve Yer”. Ed. N. Özgen, Sosyal Coğrafya. Ankara, 77-103.
• Krane J. 2009, City of Gold: Dubai and the dream of capitalism. New York.
• Litova D. 2020, “Louvre Abu-Dhabi or The Myth of Westernalism”, Concept: Philosophy, Religion, Culture, 4(13), 194-200. https://doi.org/10.24833/2541-8831-2020-1-13-194-200.
• Lusive Studio. 2019, The Museum of the Future in Dubai, Kaynak: https://lusive.com/lusivelife/post/dubais-futuristic-architecture#sthash.JEPBZAS4.QSbQ9Jd5.dpbs.
• McLean F. 1995, “Future directions for marketing in museums”. The European Journal of Cultural Policy, 1/2, 355-368.
• Mellah A. 2014, “Collecting Islamic Art: In Qatar: What’s New”. Ed. P. Erskine-Loftus, Museums and the Material World Collecting the Arabian Peninsula. Edinburgh, 296-331.
• MIA. 2023, Architecture. Kaynak: https://mia.org.qa/en/about-us/architecture/
• Miller T. & Yúdice G. 2002, Cultural Policy. London.
• Mirgani S. 2021, Investments in Cultural Infrastructure in the Gulf Countries. Kaynak: https://www.iemed.org/med-yearbook/iemed-mediterranean-yearbook-2021/
• Moghadam A. 2021, “The staging of cultural diversity in Dubai: the case of Dubai Art Fair”. Identities, 25. https://doi.org/10.1080/1070289X.2021.1933830.
• Molho J. 2020, “Modelling diversity: cultural district policies in Doha and Singapore”. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 26/6, 740-755. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286632.2020.1811250.
• Morel C. 2014, “The art fair as a metaphor of the art world”. Eds. O’Reilly, R. Rentschler and T. Kirchner, The Routledge companion to arts marketing. New York, 353-363.
• Museums Qatar. 2023, Visitor Guidelines. Kaynak: https://qm.org.qa/en/visit/visitor-guidelines/?_gl=1*j94ajn*_ga*NzM1MjE3MDMyLjE2OTY4NTc5ODU.*_ga_3XB9X561TQ*MTY5Njg1Nzk4NS4xLjEuMTY5Njg1ODAwNy4wLjAuMA.
• Naef S. 2014, “Hidden Treasures Museum Collections of Modern Art From The Arab Wolrd (1891-2010)”. Eds. I. Maffi and R. Daher, The Politcs and Practices of Cultural Heritage in The Middle East. London, 270-292.
• New World Wealth. 2023, World’s Wealthiest Cities Report 2023. Kaynak: https://www.henleyglobal.com/ publications/wealthiest-cities.
• Nisbett M. 2012, “New perspectives on instrumentalism: an emprical study of cultural diplomacy”. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 19/5, 1-19. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286632.2012.704628.
• Oakley K. & O’Connor J. 2015, “Culture and The City”. Eds. Oakley, K. & O’Connor, The Routledge Companion to The Cultural Industiries. New York, 201-211.
• Oakley K. & O'Connor J. 2015, The Routledge Companion to The Cultural Industiries. New York.
• Osborn J. & Chang K. 2009, “Building Cultural Capital: Contemporary Art in Dubai and the African Art Circuit”. Revisiting Modernization Conference Thematic Area 2: Emerging Circuits of African Art Production and Exhibition. Legon, 4-16.
• Paquette J. & Beauregar D. 2018, “Cultural policiy in political research”. Eds. V. Durrer, T. Miller and D. O’Brien, The Routledge Handbook of Global Cultural Policy. New York, 19-32.
• Petti A. 2008, “Dubai offshore urbanism”. Eds. M. Dehaene & L. De Cauter. Heterotopia and the City Public Space in a Postcivil Societ. New York, 287-296.
• Poster M. 2006, Information Please Culture and Politics in the Age of Digital Machines. Durham.
• Prager L. 2015, “Displaying Origins: Heritage Museums, Cultural Festivals, and National Imageries in the UAE”. Horizons in Humanities and Social Sciences An International Refereed Journal, 1/1, 22-46. DOI:10.19089/hhss.v1i1.14.
• Qatar General Secretariat for Development Planning. 2008, Qatar National Vision 2030, Doha: General Secretariat for Development Planning.
• Regina 2022, Post: Directors Of The Dubai Culture And Arts Authority: The Leading Role Of Women In The Cultural Movement. Kaynak: https://newsunrolled.com/opinion/89553.html.
• Renard A. L. 2021, Western privilege: work, intimacy and postcolonial hierarchies in Dubai. Stanford.
• Ritzer G. 2011, Toplumun McDonaldlaşması. Çev. Ş. S. Kaya, İstanbul.
• Rogan E. 2017, Araplar: Bir Halkın Tarihi. Çev: C. Demirkıran, İstanbul.
• Salama A. Wiedmann, F., Khalfani, F. and Al-Maimani, A., 2016, “Dynamics of Populations and Urban Open Spaces in the Emerging City of Doha”. Eds. G. Katodrytis and S. Syed, Gulf Cities as Interfaces. Cambridge, 181-202.
• Shabout N. M. 2007, Modern Arab Art Formation of Arab Aesthetics. Florida.
• Shoup J. A. 2022, The History of The United Arab Emirates. Denver.
• Sindelar M. 2016, “Local, Regional, Global: An Investigation of Art Dubai’s Transnational Strategies”. Arabian Humanities, 7. 1-18. https://doi.org/10.4000/cy.3250.
• Thorsby D. 2010, The Economics of Cultural Policy. Cambridge.
• Trötschel-Daniels B. 2022, “Cultural Diplomacy and Cultural Heritage: Envisioned, Refused, Denied, Accomplished (1889–1969)”. Eds. E. Carbó-Catalan, & D. Roig-Sanz, Culture as Soft Power. Berlin, 269-296.
• Turner G. 2015, “Cultura, Politics and The Cultural Industries Reviving a Critical Agenda”. Eds. K. Oakley, & J. O’Connor, The Routledge Companion to The Cultural Industires. New York, 535-543.
• Turner V. 2018, “The Relationship Betweeen Cultural Policy and Arts Management”. Eds. V. Durrer, T. Miller, & D. O’Brien, The Routledge Handbook of Cultural Policy. New York. 64-86.
• UNESCO World Heritage Convention. 2023, Tentative Lists. Kaynak: https://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/5662/
• Wu C. T. 2005, Kültürün Özeleştrilmesi 1980'ler Sonrasında Şirketlerin Sanata Müdahalesi. Çev: E. Soğancılar, İstanbul.
• Yayınoğlu P. E. & Susar, A. F. 2008, Kent, Görsel Kimlik ve İletişim. Kocaeli.
• Yılmaz M. 2019, “Bir Anlamlandırma Yordamı Olarak Sanat”. Felsefe Arkivi, 50, 1-7. https://doi.org/10.26650/arcp2019-589806.
• Zahlan S. 1978, The Origins of The United Arab Emirates. London.
• Zukin S. 1998, “Urban Lifestyles: Diversity and Standardisation in Spaces of Consumption”. Urban Studies, 35/5-6, 825-839.