YETİŞKİN CİNSEL SUÇ MAĞDURLARININ ADLİ GÖRÜŞME ODASI GEREKSİNİMİ

Year 2024, Volume: YOK Issue: 57, 283 - 300, 15.01.2024

Umut Haydar Coşkun

https://doi.org/10.54049/taad.1418240

Abstract

Cinsel suç mağdurlarının beyanlarının mahkeme salonlarından bağımsız bir ortamda alınma fikrinin küresel olarak yaygınlaşmasının etkisi Türkiye’de de görülmüştür. Önce 2010 yılından itibaren çocuk cinsel suç mağdurları için çocuk izlem merkezleri, ardından da 2017 yılında adalet sarayları içerisinde tüm kırılgan/dezavantajlı grupları ve yetişkin mağdurları kapsayan adli görüşme odaları kurulmaya başlamıştır. Sevindirici bir gelişme olarak adli görüşme odaları büyük bir başarı elde etmiş, kısa süre içerisinde 81 ili kapsayacak şekilde yaygınlaşmıştır. Nitekim bazı adalet saraylarında ek adli görüşme odaları açılmış, ayrıca ilçe adalet sarayların da adli görüşme odaları kurulmaya başlamıştır. Bu olumlu gelişmelerin yanında bardağın boş kısmında ise, genel bir sorun olarak yetişkin cinsel istismar mağdurlarının adli görüşme odalarından daha az faydalanması söz konusudur. Yetişkin cinsel istismar mağdurlarının da çocuk mağdurlar gibi kısa ve uzun vadede cinsel suçlardan olumsuz etkilendiği, koruyucu, destekleyici düzenlemelere, uzman desteğine ve adli görüşme odasında alınmasına gereksinim duydukları unutulmamalıdır. Kırılgan grup içerisinde yer alan yetişkin cinsel suç mağdurlarının beyanlarının adli görüşme odasında alınması uygulamasının yaygınlaşması, şüphesiz yetişkin mağdurların örselenmesini ya da ikincil mağduriyet oluşmasını önleyecektir. Ayrıca birçok çalışma göstermektedir ki, adli görüşme odası ortamı yetişkin cinsel suç mağdurların ifşa ve yargılama süreçlerine de önemli katkılar sunabilmektedir. Sonuç olarak, adli görüşme odalarının yetişkin mağdurları daha fazla kapsayacak şekilde genişlemesi mağdurların ve kırılgan grupların korunması ve desteklenmesi noktasında önemli bir adım olacaktır.

Keywords

Adli görüşme, adli görüşme odası, yetişkin cinsel suç mağdurları, sosyal çalışma görevlileri.

Ethical Statement

Bu makale Etik Kurul iznine tabi değildir/This article is not subject to Ethics Committee permission.

Forensic Interview Room Requirements of Adult Victims of Sexual Crime

Abstract

The idea of taking sexual crime victims’ statements in an environment independent of courtrooms has become widespread globally, and its effect has been seen in Turkey as well. Starting in 2010, child observation centers were established for child victims of sexual crime, and then in 2017, forensic interview rooms that include all vulnerable/disadvantaged groups and adult victims were started to be established in courthouses. As a pleasing development, the forensic interview rooms have been a great success, and they have been expanded to cover 81 provinces in a short period of time. Additional forensic interview rooms have been opened in some courthouses, and forensic interview rooms have also started to be established in district courthouses. While these developments are encouraging, they are accompanied by the fact that adult victims of sexual abuse globally have less access to forensic interview rooms. It is important to note that adult victims of sexual abuse are also negatively affected by sexual crimes in the short and long term, and need protective, supportive regulations, expert support, and their statement taken in a forensic interview room. The widespread use of the practice of taking statements from vulnerable adult victims of sexual crime in forensic interview rooms will undoubtedly prevent the adult victims from being traumatized or from secondary victimization. Furthermore, numerous studies have shown that the forensic interview room environment can make significant contributions to the disclosure and judgement processes of adult victims of sexual crime. In conclusion, it is believed that the expansion of forensic interview rooms to include more adult victims will be an important step in protecting and supporting victims and vulnerable groups.

Keywords

Forensic interview, forensic interview room, adult victims of sexual crime, social workers.

Ethical Statement

Bu makale Etik Kurul iznine tabi değildir/This article is not subject to Ethics Committee permission.

References

• Adalet Bakanlığı Adli Destek ve Mağdur Hizmetleri Müdürlüğü. Adli Görüşme Odaları (2021) <https://rayp.adalet.gov.tr/resimler/1/dosya/142021084114176noluagogenelge01-04-202109-53.pdf> Erişim Tarihi: 10.07.2023
• Adalet Bakanlığı, Adli Görüşme Odaları Yönetmeliği (2021) <https://cigm.adalet.gov.tr/Resimler/SayfaDokuman/232020114201ADL%C4%B0%20G%C3%96R%C3%9C%C5%9EME%20ODALARI%20Y%C3%96NETMEL%C4%B0%C4%9E%C4%B0.pdf> Erişim Tarihi: 03.08.2023
• Bach MH, Hansen NB, Ahrens C, Nielsen CR, Walshe C ve Hansen M, “Underserved Survivors of Sexual Assault: A Systematic Scoping Review.” (2021) 12(1) European Journal of Psychotraumatology 1-15.
• Baker MA, Frazier P, Greer C, Paulsen JA, Howard K, Meredith L, Anders SA ve Shallcross SA, “Sexual Victimization History Predicts Academic Performance in College Women” (2016) 63(6) Journal of Counseling Psychology 685-692.
• Beck R, “We Believe the Children: A Moral Panic in the 1980s.” (1. Bası, Public Affairs, 2015).
• Bilginer SÇ ve Çalışkan D, “Çocuğu İstismardan Korumada Yeni Bir Yaklaşım: Çocuk İzlem Merkezleri.” İç Yasemin Karaman-Kepenekci ve Pelin Taşkın (eds.), “Prof. Dr. Emine Akyüz’e Armağan: Akademisyenlikte 50 yıl. Çocuk Hakları, Eğitim Hukuku, Vatandaşlık Eğitimi” (1. Bası, Pegem Akademi 2018).
• Blanco V, López L, Otero P, Torres AJ, Ferraces MJ ve Vázquez FL, “Sexual Victimization and Mental Health in Female University Students.” (2022) 37(15) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 1,23.
• Boldsad BR ve Zinbarg RE, “Sexual Victimization, Generalized Perception of Control, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Symptom Severity” (1997) 11(5) Journal of Anxiety Disorders 523-540.
• Borelli JL, Cohen C, Pettit C, Normandin L, Target M, Fonagy P ve Ensink K, “Maternal and Child Sexual Abuse History: An Intergenerational Exploration of Children’s Adjustment and Maternal Trauma-Reflective Functioning.” (2019) 10(1) Frontiers in Psychology 1062-1062.
• Boyd CR, “The Impacts of Sexual Assault on Women” (1. Bası, Australian Institute of Family Studies, 2011).
• Bracewell TM, “Outcry Consistency and Prosecutorial Decisions in Child Sexual Abuse Cases.” (2018) 27(4) Journal of Child Sexual Abuse 424-438.
• Campbell R, Javorka M, Gregory K, Vollinger L ve Ma W, “The Right to Say No: Why Adult Sexual Assault Patients Decline Medical Forensic Exams and Sexual Assault Kit Evidence Collection” (2021) 17(1) Journal of Forensic Nursing 3-13.
• Canavan JW, Borowski C, Essex S ve Perkowski S, “Multidisciplinary Responses to the Sexual Victimization of Children: Use of Control Phone Calls.” (2021) 36(1) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 384-401.
• Ceci SJ ve Bruck M, “Jeopardy in the Courtroom: A Scientific Analysis of Children’s Testimony.” (1. Bası, American Psychological Association, 1995).
• Çağlar EE ve Türk T, “İstismara Maruz Kalan Çocuklarla Adli Görüşme: NICHD Protokolü Önerisi” (2019) 38(1) Türkiye Adalet Akademisi Dergisi 393-412.
• Delcea CA, Fabian M, Radu CC ve Dumbravă DP, “Juvenile Delinquency within the Forensic Context” (2019) 27(4) Romanian Journal of Legal Medicine 366-372.
• Dierenfeldt R ve Balemba S, “Male Sexual Victimization: Examining Variation in the Probability of Weapon Use and Victim Injury” (2021) 36(11) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 1-29.
• Dworkin ER, Jaffe AE, Bedard-Gilligan M ve Fitzpatrick S, “PTSD in the Year Following Sexual Assault: A Meta-Analysis of Prospective Studies.” (2023) 24(2) Trauma, Violence, & Abuse 497-514.
• Dworkin ER, Krahé B ve Zinzow H, “The Global Prevalence of Sexual Assault: A Systematic Review of International Research Since 2010.” (2021) 11(5) Psychology of Violence 497-508.
• Ernberg E, Magnusson M, Landström S ve Tidefors I, “Court Evaluations of Young Children’s Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Cases.” (2018) 23(2) Legal and Criminological Psychology 176-191.
• Faller KC, “Forty Years of Forensic Interviewing of Children Suspected of Sexual Abuse, 1974–2014: Historical Benchmarks.”(2014) 4(1) Social Sciences 34-65.
• Gajadhar S ve Bull R, “The Non-Stranger Rapist-Oriented Interview for Complainants: Eliciting High-Quality Accounts” (2023) 96(3) The Police Journal 1-23.
• Gökçen FG, “Kırılgan Mağdurun Beyanının CMK’nın 236. Maddesi Uyarınca Alınması ve Uygulanan Özel Usuller Karşısında Savunma Hakkının Dengelenmesi.” (2021) 153 TBB Dergisi (2021): 1-38.
• Hailes HP, Yu R, Danese A ve Fazel S, “Long-Term Outcomes of Childhood Sexual Abuse: An Umbrella Review.” (2019) 6(10) The Lancet Psychiatry 830-839.
• Juliann Whetsell Mitchell, “Rape of the Innocent: Understanding and Preventing Child Sexual Abuse”. (1. Bası, Taylor & Francis, 2023).
• Knack N, Winder B, Murphy L ve Fedoroff JP. “Primary and Secondary Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse.” (2019) 31(2) International Review of Psychiatry 181-194.
• Krause-Parello C, Thames M, Ray CM ve Kolassa J, “Examining The Effects of a Service-Trained Facility Dog on Stress in Children Undergoing Forensic Interview for Allegations of Child Sexual Abuse.” (2020) 27(3) Journal of Child Sexual Abuse 305-320.
• Laney C ve Loftus EF, “History of Forensic Interviewing” Forensic Interviews Regarding Child Sexual Abuse: A Guide to Evidence-Based Practice (1. Bası, Springer International Publishing 2016)
• Lombardi BN, Jensen T, Parisi AB, Jenkins M ve Bledsoe SE, “The Relationship between a Lifetime History of Sexual Victimization and Perinatal Depression: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” (2023) 24(1) Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 139-155.
• Nicol SJ, Harris DA, Ogilvie J, Kebbell MR, Craig C ve Knight R, “Evading Detection: What Do We Know about Men Charged with Extrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse Following Delayed Detection?.” (2022) 31(3) Journal of Child Sexual Abuse 333-352.
• Nitschke FT, McKimmie BM ve Vanman EJ. “A Meta-Analysis of the Emotional Victim Effect for Female Adult Rape Complainants: Does Complainant Distress Influence Credibility?.” (2019) 145(10) Psychological Bulletin 953-979.
• Odacı H ve Türkkan T, “Cinsel İstismar Şüphesi Bulunan Çocukla Görüşme: Öğretmenler ve Okul Psikolojik Danışmanları Nasıl Davranmalı ve Neler Yapmalı?.” (2021) 19(1) Türk Eğitim Bilimleri Dergisi 685-706.
• Oesterle DW, Jarnecke AM ve Gilmore AK, “Sexual Re-Assault among College Women Differs Based on Sexual Refusal Assertiveness and Assertive Resistance Strategy Intentions.” (2022) 37(19) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 473-491.
• Papp JL ve McClelland Sara I, “Too Common to Count? “Mild” Sexual Assault and Aggression among US College Women.” (2021) 58(4) The Journal of Sex Research 488-501.
• Ports KA, Ford DC ve Merrick MT, “Adverse Childhood Experiences and Sexual Victimization in Adulthood” (2016) 51(1) Child Abuse & Neglect 313-322.
• Powell MP ve Cauchi R, “Victims’ Perceptions of a New Model of Sexual Assault Investigation Adopted by Victoria Police” (2013) 14(3) Police Practice and Research 228-241.
• Powers RA ve Hayes BE, “Victim and Third-Party Reporting of Violent Victimization to the Police in Incidents Involving Victims with Disabilities” (2022) 22 Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 1-35.
• Pulverman CS, Kilimnik CD ve Meston CM, “The Impact of Childhood Sexual Abuse on Women’s Sexual Health: A Comprehensive Review.” (2018) 6(2) Sexual Medicine Reviews 188-200.
• Riggs Romaine CL, “Functional Deficits in Juveniles Evaluated for Adjudicative Competence.” (2022) 49(5) Criminal Justice and Behavior 638-659
• Rochelle FH ve Adams CS, “Childhood sexual abuse: identification, screening, and treatment recommendations in primary care settings.” (2016) 43(2) Primary Care: Clinics in Office Practice 313-326.
• Sarıca AD ve Coşkun UH, “Cinsel İstismar Olgularında Adli Görüşme Odalarının Kullanımı: Hâkim, Avukat, Uzman ve Mağdur Görüşleri.” (2020) 8(1) Journal of Penal Law and Criminology 117-142.
• Schols MWA, De Ruiter C ve Öry FG, “How do Public Child Healthcare Professionals and Primary School Teachers Identify and Handle Child Abuse Cases? A Qualitative Study.” (2013) 13(1) BMC Public Health, 1-16.
• Shoemaker DJ, Juvenile Delinquency. (6. Bası, Rowman & Littlefield, 2017)
• Stewart ML, Shackel R, Freedman E ve Templeton DJ, “Adult Sexual Assault Patients’ Experience of the Physical Examination Component of the Medical Forensic Examination: A Scoping Review to Identify Gaps in the Research Literature.” (2023) 24(4) Trauma, Violence, & Abuse 1-17.
• Şamar, B ve Urhan, B, “Adli Görüşme Odalarında Suç Mağdurlarıyla Görüşme Yapan Adli Görüşmecilerin Deneyimlerinin İncelenmesi: Eskişehir Adliyesi.» (2020) 31(3) Toplum ve Sosyal Hizmet Dergisi 931-959.
• T.C. Adalet Bakanlığı Ceza İşleri Müdürlüğü Mağdur Hakları Daire Başkanlığı, “Adli Görüşme Odaları: AGO Uygulaması için Temel Hukuk Bilgisi” (2020) <http://www.magdur.adalet.gov.tr/images/ago-hukuk.pdf> Erişim Tarihi: 15.07.2023.
• T.C. Adalet Bakanlığı Mağdur Hakları Daire Başkanlığı “AGO Bulunan Adliyeler” (2023) <https://magdur.adalet.gov.tr/Home/SayfaDetay/ago-bulunan-adliyeler> Erişim Tarihi: 12.07.2023.
• T.C. Adalet Bakanlığı Mağdur Hakları Daire Başkanlığı “AGO nedir?” (2023) <https://magdur.adalet.gov.tr/Home/SayfaDetay/agonedir> Erişim Tarihi: 12.07.2023
• T.C. Sağlık Bakanlığı “Çocuk İzlem Merkezleri Listesi” (2023) <https://khgmsaglikhizmetleridb.saglik.gov.tr/TR-43119/cocuk-izlem-merkezi-cim-listesi.html> Erişim Tarihi: 08.07.2023.
• Taner, FG “Türk Ceza Hukukunda Cinsel Özgürlüğe Karşı Suçlar” (3. Bası, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2023).
• Taner, FG, “Kırılgan Mağdurun Beyanının CMK’nın 236. Maddesi Uyarınca Alınması ve Uygulanan Özel Usuller Karşısında Savunma Hakkının Dengelenmesi.” (2021) 153 Türkiye Barolar Birliği Dergisi (2021): 1, 2.
• Thompson, MP ve Kingree, JB. “Adverse Childhood Experiences, Sexual Victimization, and Suicide Ideation and Attempts: A Longitudinal Path Analysis Spanning 22 years.” (2022) 92(3) American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 302-309.
• Walsh, WA ve Meunier-Sham, J, “Using Telehealth for Pediatric, Adolescent, and Adult Sexual Assault Forensic Medical Examinations: An Integrative Review.” (2020) 16(4) Journal of Forensic Nursing 232-239.
• Werner, KB, McCutcheon, VV, Challa, M, Agrawal, A, Lynskey, MT, Conroy, E ve Statham, D “The Association between Childhood Maltreatment, Psychopathology, and Adult Sexual Victimization in Men and Women: Results from Three Independent Samples” (2016) 46(3) Psychological Medicine 563-573.
• William O’Donohue “A Forensic Interview Protocol for Adult Sexual Assault: Content Validity and Consumer Acceptability.” (2021) 21(2) International Journal of Psychology and Psychological Therapy 133-147.
• Wiss, DA, Brewerton, TD ve Tomiyama, AJ. “Limitations of the Protective Measure Theory in Explaining the Role of Childhood Sexual Abuse in Eating Disorders, Addictions, and Obesity: An Updated Model with Emphasis on Biological Embedding.” (2022) 27(4) Eating and Weight Disorders-Studies on Anorexia, Bulimia and Obesity 1249-1267.
• World Health Organization. Violence Against Women: Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence against Women: Evidence Brief. No. WHO/RHR/19.16. (1. Bası World Health Organization, 2019).
• Xin, S ve Zheng, Y, “Sexual Victimization in Adulthood and Associated Factors among Men and Women: Cross-Sectional Evidence from Mainland China” (2022) 51(2) Archives of Sexual Behavior 1001-1017.