The Gem Stamp on the Handle of a Mushroom-rimmed Amphora from Knidos: An Assessment of the Centauromachy in Terms of Stamps and Iconography

Yıl 2020, Sayı: 23, 239 - 252, 15.11.2020

Erkan Alkaç Ulus Tepebaş

https://doi.org/10.47589/adalya.837672

Öz

In 1973 a fragment of a stamped amphora with a mushroom-shaped rim was found during archaeological excavations at the “West Harbour Byzantine Church E” in Knidos. The gem-shaped stamp on the handle of this amphora features a mythological scene of a battle between a Centaur and a Lapith. The figure on the right-hand side of the scene on the gem stamp is the Lapith while the half human-half horse figure on the left is the Centaur. The heads and faces of both figures have eroded. Nevertheless, it is possible to provide information about their compositions on the scene. The torso of the Lapith figure on the right is depicted frontally, while the left leg is depicted from the side and right leg from the front. Mushroom-rimmed amphorae were produced at numerous centers across the southern Aegean region including Samos, Rhodes, Knidos, Kos, Halikarnassos, Peparethos, Klazomenai and Phokaia. The mushroomrimmed amphora, the subject of this article,
must have been produced in the Aegean region or nearby. The production of mushroomrimmed amphorae is regarded as a reflection of a regional perception. Although these amphorae generally abide by the same form, some differences in shape can be observed. Stamps are rarely found on mushroom-rimmed amphorae.
The stamps on this shape often consist of monograms and ligatures, not mythological scenes like that of the Lapith and Centaur. The depiction of this battle on the Knidos find is a unique example. This mushroom-rimmed amphora should be dated to the second half of the 4th century BCE based on similar examples in terms of form.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Knidos, mushroom-rimmed amphora, gem amphora stamp, Lapith, Centaur

Teşekkür

This study was conducted with the Decision of the Council of Ministers with no. 2013/5387 on the date 30.09.2013 and was done with the permission of the Knidos Excavation Directorship in accordance with the scope of Knidos Excavation and Research carried out on behalf of Selçuk University and the Ministry of Culture and Tourism. We are grateful to the Knidos excavation director, Prof. Dr. Ertekin M. Doksanaltı, for issuing the necessary permissions for us to study this fragment and for sharing his ideas on it. We would also like to thank Prof. Dr. Gonca Cankardeş Şenol and Assoc. Prof. Dr. Erkan Dündar for sharing their ideas on the amphora’s shape and stamp, and Songül Sözel (MA) for drawing the amphora. The study of the Centauromachy iconography on the stamp was carried out by Dr. Ulus Tepebaş in 2019 in the AKMED library as an AKMED scholarship holder while participating in the Monetary History and Numismatics Summer School. We would like to thank the AKMED authorities for this opportunity.

Kaynakça

• Apollodoros, Bib. Frazer, J. G. 1921. Bibliotheka. The Library. New York/London: William Heinemann.
• Homeros, Odys. Erhat, A., and A. Kadir. trans. 2008. Homeros, Odysseia. Istanbul: Can Yayınları.
• Homeros, Il. Butler, S. 1889. Homeros, Illias. The Illiad of Homer. London: Hanson & Co. At the Ballantyne Press.
• Alkaç, E. 2019. “Knidos Kazılarında Bulunan Amphora Mühürleri Üzerine İlk Değerlendirmeler.” Arkhaia Anatolika 2:84-101.
• Barringer, J.M. 2009. “A New Approach to the Hephaisteion: Heroic Models in the Athenian Agora.” In Structure, Image, Ornament: Architectural Sculpture in the Greek World, Proceedings of an International Conference held at the American School of Classical Studies, 27-28 November 2004, edited by P. Schultz and R. von den Hoff, 121-32. Oxford/Oakville, CT: Oxbow Books.
• Baur, P.V.C. 1912. The Centaurs in Ancient Art, the Archaic Period. Berlin: Karl Curtius.
• Beazley, J.D. 1963. Attic Red-Figure Vase-Painters. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
• Benndorf, O., and G. Niemann. 1889. Das Heroon von Gjölbaschi-Trysa. Jahrbuch der kunsthistorischen Sammlungen des allerhöchsten Kaiserhauses 9. Vienna: Adolf Holzhausen.
• Borchhardt, J., and G. Stanzl. 1990. “Ein hellenistischer Bau des Herrscherkultes: Das Ptolemaion von Lymra.” In Götter, Heroen, Herrscher in Lykien, edited by J. Borchhardt, R. Jacobek, and A. Dinstl, 79-84. Vienna: A. Schroll.
• Cankardeş-Şenol, G. 2001. “Metropolis’den Hellenistik Döneme Ait Bir Grup Amphora Mühürü.” Olba 4:101-14.
• Cankardeş-Şenol, G. 2006. Klasik ve Hellenistik Dönem‘de Mühürlü Amphora Üreten Merkezler ve Mühürleme Sistemleri. Istanbul: Ege Yayınları.
• Cankardeş-Şenol, G. 2010. “Nikandros Group: Matrix Studies on the Amphora Stamps of the Group.” Olba 18:125-39.
• Cankardeş-Şenol, G. 2015. “Early Cnidian Amphora Exports to Alexandria, Egypt.” In Recent Studies on the Archaeology of Anatolia, edited by E. Laflı and S. Patacı, 169-92. BAR-IS 2750. Oxford: Archaeopress. Publishers of British Archaeological Reports.
• Childs, W.A.P. 1978. The City-Reliefs of Lycia. Princeton Monographs in Art and Archaeology 42. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
• Coşkun, G., and F. Çevirici-Coşkun. 2017. “Seyitömer Höyük M.Ö. 5. ve 4. Yüzyıl Ticari Amphoraları.” Ege Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Arkeoloji Dergisi 22:229-43.
• Delivorrias, A. 1969. “Poseidon Tempel auf Kap Sounion Neue Fragme nte der Friesdekoration.” AM 84:127-42.
• Desborough, V.R.d’A., R.V. Nicholls, and M.R. Popham. 1970. “A Euboean Centaur.” BSA 65:21-30.
• Dinsmoor, W.B. 1975. The Architecture of Ancient Greece: An Account of its Historic Development. 3rd ed. New York: W.W. Norton.
• Doğer, E. 1986. “Premières remarques sur les amphores de Clazomènes.” In Recherces sur les Amphores Grecques, edited by J.-Y. Empereur and Y. Garlan, 461-71, BCH Suppl. 13. Athens/Paris: École Française d’Athènes/de Boccard.
• Doğer, E., and A.K. Şenol. 1996. “Rhodos Peraiası’nda İki Yeni Amphora Atölyesi.” Ege Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Arkeoloji Dergisi 4:59-73.
• Doksanaltı, E.M., İ. Karaoğlan, and D.O. Tozluca. 2018. Knidos. Denizlerin Buluştuğu Kent. Ankara: Bilgin Kültür ve Sanat Yayınları.
• Doksanaltı, E.M., İ. Karaoğlan, E. Aslan, İ.M. Mimiroğlu, L.U. Erdoğan, D.O. Tozluca, and G. Ünver. 2019. “Knidos Kazı ve Araştırmaları: 2017.” Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı 40.2:45-64.
• Doulgéri-Intzessiloglou, A., and Y. Garlan. 1990. “Vin et amphores de Péparéthos et d’Ikos.” BCH 114.1:361-89.
• Dündar, E. 2017. Transport Jars and Stamped Amphoras from Patara, 7th to 1st Centuries BC. The Maritime Trade of a Harbor City in Lycia. Patara 4.3. Istanbul: Ege Yayınları.
• Empereur, J.-Y., and M. Picon. 1986. “Des ateliers d‘amphores à Paros et à Naxos.” BCH 110.1:495-511.
• Felten, F., and K. Hoffelner. 1987. “Die Relieffriese des Poseidontempels in Sunion.” AM 102:169-84.
• Hasdağlı, İ. 2012. “The Assessment of the 4th Century B.C. Finds from Three Wells Uncovered at Clazomenae HBT (Hamdi Balaban Tarlası) Sector.” Olba 20:119-64.
• Hölscher, T. 2000. “Feindwelten, Glückswelten. Perser, Kentauren und Amazonen.” In Gegenwelten: zu den Kulturen Griechenlands und Roms in der Antike, edited by T. Hölscher, 287-320. München/Leipzig: Saur.
• Georgopoulou, B. 2001. “Κωακοι Αμφορεις απο την Καρδαμαινα (Αρχαια Αλασαρνα) της Κω.” In Ιστορία - Τἑχνη - Αρχαιολογία της Κω. Α’Διεθνἑς Επιστημονικὀ Συνἑδριο, Κως, 2-4 Μαιου 1997, edited by G. Kokkorou-Aleura, A.A. Laimou, and E. Semantone-Mpournia, 107-14. Athens: Panepistemio Athenon.
• Grace, V., and M. Savvatianou-Petropoulakou. 1970. “Les timbres amphoriques Grecs.” In L’ilot de la Maison des Comédiens, edited by P. Bruneau and T. Homelle, 277-382. Délos 27. Paris: De Boccard.
• Grace, V. 1971. “Samian Amphoras.” Hesperia 40.3:52-95.
• Jefremow, N. 2013. “Ceramic Stamps of the Late Classical - The Early Hellenistic Knidos. ‘Protoknidian’ Stamps and the Stamps with the ‘Ship’s Bow’.” Questions of Epigraphy 7.1:405-51.
• Jenkins, I. 2006. Greek Architecture and Its Sculpture. Boston: Harvard University Press.
• Jenkins, I. 2007. The Parthenon Sculptures in the British Museum. London: British Museum Press.
• Kantzia, Kh. 1994. “Ἐνα κεραμικὀ εργαστήριο αμφορέων του πρώτου μισού του 4ου αι. π.Χ. στην Κω.” In Γ’ Επιστημονική Συνάντηση για την Ελληνιστική Κεραμική: “Χρονολογημένα Σύνολα Εργαστήρια”. Θεσσαλονίκη, 24-27 Σεπτεμβρίου 1991, 323-54. Athens: Βιβλιοθήκη της εν Αθήναις Αρχαιολογικής Εταιρείας.
• Karageorghis, V.A. 1966. “Notes on Some Centaurs from Cyprus.” In Χαριστήριον εις Αναστάσιον Κ. Ορλάνδον, edited by V.A. Karageorghis, 160-69. Athens: Library of the Athens Archaeological Society.
• Lagerlöf, M.R. 2000. The Sculptures of the Parthenon: Aesthetics and Interpretation. New Haven/London: Yale University Press.
• Lawall, M.L. 1995. “Transport Amphoras and Trademarks: Imports to Athens and Economic Diversity in the Fifth Century B.C.” Ph.D. diss., Michigan University.
• Lawall, M.L. 2004a. “Archaeological Context and Aegean Amphora Chronologies: A Case Study of Hellenistic Ephesos.” In Transport Amphorae and Trade in the Eastern Mediterranean. Acts of the International Colloquium at the Danish Institute at Athens. September 26-29, 2002, edited by J. Eiring and J. Lund, 171-88. Monographs of the Danish Institute at Athens 5. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press.
• Lawall, M.L. 2004b. “Amphoras without Stamps: Chronologies and Typologies from the Athenian Agora.” In ΣΤ´ Eπιστημονική συνάντηση για την ελληνιστική Kεραμική: προβλήματα χρονολόγησης κλειστά σύνολα - εργαστήρια, Βόλος 17-23 Απριλίου 2000, 445-54. Athens: Πρaκτικά.
• Mendel, G. 1914. Musées impériaux ottomans: Catalogue des sculptures grecques, romaines et byzantines, tome 3. Constantinople: Musée Impérial.
• Monachov, S.J. 1999. “Towards a Typology of Knidian Amphoras of the 4th-2nd c. BC. / K tipologii knidskikh amfor IV-II vv. do. n.e.” In The Bosporan Phenomenon: Greek Culture on the Periphery of the Ancient World/Bosporskii fenomen: Grecheskaia kultura na periferii antichnogo mira: materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, edited by M.J. Vakhtina, 161-72. St. Petersburg.
• Monakhov, S.Y., E.V. Kuznetsova, and N.B. Churekova. 2017. Amphorae of the 5th-2nd c. BC. from the Collection of the State Museum-Preserve «Tauric Chersonese». Catalogue. Saratov: Novӱї proekt Press.
• Morgan, C.H. 1962. “The Sculptures of Hephaisteion II. The Friezes.” Hesperia 31.3:221-35.
• Papuci-Wladyka, E. 1997. “A Research Report on Hellenistic Pottery: Cos Amphoras.” Studies in Ancient Art and Civilization 8:47-54.
• Patay-Horváth, A., 2015. “Introduction. Adopting a New Approach to the Temple and its Sculptural Decoration.” In New Approaches to the Temple of Zeus at Olympia, Proceedings of the First Olympia-Seminar, 8th-10th May 2014, edited by A. Patay-Horváth, 1-14. London: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
• Padgett, J.M., W.A.P. Childs, and D. Tsiafakis. 2003. The Centaur’s Smile: The Human Animal in Early Greek Art. Princeton: Princeton University Art Museum.
• Podlecki, A.J. 1971. “Cimon, Skyros, and ‘Theseus’ Bones.” JHS 91:141-43.
• Ridgway, B.S. 1999. Prayers in Stone: Greek Architectural Sculpture (c. 600-100 B.C.E.). Sather Classical Lectures. Vol. 63. California: University of California Press.
• Roscher, H.W. 1890-1894. Ausführliches Lexikon der griechischen und römischen Mythologie. Band 2, Abteilung 1, lache-Kyzikos. Leipzig: Druck und Verlag von B.G. Teubner.
• Ruggendorfer, P. 2016. Das Mausoleum von Belevi. Archäologische Untersuchungen zu Chronologie, Ausstattung und Stiftung. Ephesos 6.2. Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
• Özbay, F. 2019. “Klazomenai FGT (Feride Gül Tarlası) Sektöründen Ele Geçen İthal Ticari Amphoralar.” Dumlupınar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 59:74-94.
• Sakarya, İ. 2016. “Trade Relations of Ancient Burgaz from Archaic to Mid of 4th Centuries: The Amphorae Evidence within the Domestic Contexts.” Ph.D. diss., Ortadoğu Teknik University.
• Schiffler, B. 1976. Die Typologie des Kentauren in der antiken Kunst vom 10. bis zum Ende des 4. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. Archäologische Studien 4. Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
• Şenol, A.K. 1995. “Erken Knidos Amphoralarında (İ.Ö. III. Yüzyıl) Monogram Mühürleri.” Master’s thesis, Ege University.
• Şenol, A.K., and E. Aşkın. 2007. “Amphoralar Işığında Kentin Ticari İlişkileri.” In Dağlık Kilikia’da Bir Antik Kent Kazısının Sonuçları, Nagidos. Results of an Excavation in an Ancient City in Rough Cilicia, edited by S. Durugönül, 241-97. Adalya Suppl. 6. Istanbul: AKMED.
• Şenol, A.K., 2009. “AETAM’da Bulunan Amphoraların Tipolojisi.” In AETAM’da (Arslan Eyce Taşucu Amphora Müzesi) Bulunan Ticari Amphoralar ve Akdeniz’de Ticaretin İzleri, edited by A.K. Şenol, 100-319. Silifke: Taşeli Matbaacılık.
• Şenol, A.K. 2015a. “Smyrna Kazılarında 2011-2007 Yılları Arasında Bulunan Ticari Amphoralar.” In Smyrna/İzmir Kazı ve Araştırmaları 1. Çalıştay Bildirileri, edited by A. Ersoy and G. Şakar, 243-56. Antik Smyrna Kazısı Yayın Çalışmaları 3. Istanbul: Ege Yayınları.
• Şenol, A.K. 2015b. “New Evidences on the Amphora Production in the Rhodian Peraea during the Early Hellenistic Period.” In Recent Studies on the Archaeology of Anatolia, edited by E. Laflı and S. Patacı, 193-201. BAR-IS 2750. Oxford: Archaeopress.
• Tarbell, F.B. 1920. “Centauromachy and Amazonomachy in Greek Art: The Reasons for Their Popularity.” AJA 24.3:226-31.
• Tuna, N., J.-Y. Empereur, M. Picon, and E. Doğer. 1987. “Rapport préliminaire de la prospection archéologique Turco-Française des ateliers d’amphores de Reşadiye-Kiliseyanı, sur la Péninsule de Datça.” Anatolia Antiqua 1:47-52.
• Tuna, N. 1990. “Datça Yarımadasında Hellenistik Dönem Amphora Üretim Merkezleri.” In X. Türk Tarih Kongresi, I. Cilt, 22-26 Eylül 1986, 347-71. Ankara: Türk Tarih Kurumu.
• Zeest, I.B. 1960. Keramicheskaia tara Bospora. Materialy i issledovaniia po arkheologii SSSR 83. Moskova: Izd-vo Akademii nauk SSSR.