Post-genocidal Balkans Peace: Human Justice, Morality, Memory and Oblivion

Yıl 2021, Sayı: 7, 89 - 112, 31.12.2021

Faruk Hadžić

Öz

This paper critically addresses the identification of transitional, retributive and restorative justice, ICTY, and historiographical memory as the moral foundation of conflict transformation and peace-building normativeness in post-Yugoslav societies. First, the paper argues that Western Balkans’ socio-political maturity depends on the moral exactitude of legal justice and ethnopolitical collective identity mechanism within conflicting memory order. Second, it questions the significant objective between memory and oblivion. Memory is a justice contributor but could affect peace, reconciliation, social progression, and development. Given humanity’s propensity for violence, then at the very least, forgetfulness and the sacrifices it imposes may be a cause for relief rather than outrage after the most critical aspects of transitional, retributive, and restorative justice are fulfilled. The meaning and significance of self-defense against the committed genocide require solicitude for conscience and moral questioning. Third, national/ethnoreligious collective denial inducted by the politically encouraged culture of fear and ethnoreligious antagonism is critical for a liberal peace stalemate and social (in)justice. Thus, a decades-long political matrix regarding the “ethnonational interest” and ethnic patriotic collectivism departed as exceptional nationalism. Finally, these circumstances make human (universal) justice principles an open question.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Balkans, ICTY, former Yugoslavia, Transitional, Retributive and Restorative justice, Genocide, Memory, Ethnopolitics, Peace, Morality

Kaynakça

• Camus, Albert, The just assasins, Paris, Gallimard, 1949.
• David, Lea. 2020. The Past Cannot Heal Us, The Dangers of Mandating memory in the Name of Human Rights. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Dostoevsky, Fjodor, The Demons, New York, Everyman's Library, 2000.
• Hadžić, Faruk. 2020. The Politicization of Religion and the Sacralized Balkan Nations Regarding Bosnia and Herzegovina, Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, 40(7), 105-132 https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/ree/vol40/iss7/8
• Hadžić, Faruk. 2021. Agnosticism and Atheism as Amoralism and Anti-Ideological Sociopolitical Paradigm in the Balkans, Specifically in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, 41(2), 68-85 https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/ree/vol41/iss2/6
• Hadžić, Faruk. 2021. Ethnoreligious political dispute, conflict management, leadership, and civic inclusion: the Balkans and globally, Istanbul Aydin Universitesi Dergisi [Istanbul Aydin University Journal of Social Sciences].13(3):16 10.17932/IAU.IAUSBD.2021.021/iausbd_v13i3003
• Hadžić, Faruk, Agnosticism and Atheism as Amoralism and Anti-Ideological Sociopolitical Paradigm in the Balkans, Specifically in Bosnia and Herzegovina, OPREE Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, Vol 41, Issue 2, Article 6, (2021) https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/ree/vol41/iss2/6/ Halimović, Dzenana. 2017. Slobodna Europa, Zarije Seizović: Tri istine u BiH“ [Zarije Seizović: Three truths in BiH] https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/bosna-i-hercegovina-pravosudje-zarije-seizovic/28789541.html
• Hartman, Florence. 2012. Pescanik, Negiranje duple agresije [Denial of double ceime], https://pescanik.net/negiranje-duple-agresije-u-bih
• Huntington, Samuel. 1996. The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, New York, Simon & Schuster
• Ilic, Dejan. 2016. Pescanik, Beskompromisni patriotizam Srđe Popovica [Srdja Popovic's uncompromising patriotism]. https://pescanik.net/beskompromisni-patriotizam-srde-popovica/
• Ilic, Dejan. 2018. Pescanik, Rat umjesto tranzicije [The war instead of transition] Rat umesto tranzicije DEJAN ILIĆ14/08/2018
• Jensen, Anthony and Santini Carlota (editors), 2020. Nietzsche on Memory and History: The Re-Encountered Shadow, Berlin. De Gruyter
• Kearney, Richard. 2002. On stories, UK: Rutledge.
• Kovalovska, Adriana. 1997. Rape of muslim women in wartime Bosnia. ILSA Journal of Int'l & Comparative Law, Vol. 3: 931-945 https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/51088972.pdf
• Lucic, Predrag. 2008. Pescanik. Govor. https://pescanik.net/govor/
• Neuffer, Elisabeth. 2002. The Key to My Neighbor's House: Seeking Justice in Bosnia and Rwanda. London: Picador.
• Neumann, Franz. 2017. Anxiety and Politics, Journal for a Global Sustainable Information Society, 15(2). https://doi.org/10.31269/triplec.v15i2.901
• Perica, Vjekoslav. 2016. Radio Gornji Grad, "Hrvatska Je danas najjača scena etničkog i klerikalnog nacionalizma na Balkanu "[Today, Croatia is the most vital scene of ethnic and clerical nationalism in the Balkans] https://radiogornjigrad.wordpress.com/2016/02/19/dr-vjekoslav-perica-hrvatska-je-danas-najjaca-scena-etnickog-i-klerikalnog-nacionalizma-na-balkanu/
• Perica, Vjekoslav, 2019. Pescanik, Pomirenje i posljedni dani [Reconciliation and the last days] https://pescanik.net/pomirenje-i-posljednji-dani/
• Perica, Vjekoslav. 2019. Pescanik, Willy Brandt u balkanskom getu [Will Brandt in the Balkan ghetto], Pescanik. https://pescanik.net/willy-brandt-u-balkanskom-getu/
• Riedlmayer, Andreas. 2002. Expert report titled 'Destruction of Cultural Heritage in Bosnia and Herzegovina. http://hdl.handle.net/11134/20009:P02503
• Sabljakovic, Dzevad. 2012. Deutsche Welle, DW, Suđenje Mladiću za dvostruki genocid [Trial of Mladic for Double Genocide]
• Sekulic, Marinko. 2019. Deutsche welle, Ubijeni na kucnom pragu [Killed "on the doorstep], https://www.dw.com/hr/ubijeni-na-ku%C4%87nom-pragu/a-47208075
• Teitel, Ruti. 2002. Transitional Justice in a New Era, Fordham: Fordham University Press. https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj/vol26/iss4/2
• Zorlak, Kemal, AA, Dan džamija: Od rata do sada u BiH obnovljeno 1.175 džamija i mesdžida, 2018. https://www.aa.com.tr/ba/balkan/dan-d%C5%BEamija-od-rata-do-sada-u-bih-obnovljeno-1175-d%C5%BEamija-i-mesd%C5%BEida/1137409
• Case no. IT-04-74-T, ICTY, Second amended indictment: Prosecutor of the ICTY Tribunal. 2017.
• Serb population in Croatia, https://s29.postimg.org/3sjgmh447/Karolj1.png