HUNGARY’S POSITION ON THE RUSSIA-UKRAINE WAR AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR COOPERATION IN THE VISEGRAD GROUP

Yıl 2023, Cilt: 5 Sayı: 4, 7 - 26, 31.10.2023

Fulya Akgül Durakçay

Öz

Visegrad Group (V4) composed of Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia is a significant subregional partnership that has influenced the European Union’s policies particularly in the area of migration policies. Although the group does not always speak with one voice in every policy area, Hungary became particularly estranged from the V4 due to its differing position on the Russia-Ukraine war. This study analyses the implications of Hungary’s stance on the Russia-Ukraine war for the V4 cooperation. With this aim, it overviews the importance of the V4 in furthering Hungary’s interests, searches for economic and political considerations influencing Hungary’s position on the Russia- Ukraine war, and discusses the diverging positions of the rest of the block on the war with its implications for the V4 cooperation. The study benefits from the analysis of primary sources such as the V4 declarations and official statements, Hungarian presidency programs, Orbán’s statements as well as the news and the secondary research. The study finds out that Hungary endorses the unified EU stance as long as it does not contradict its core interests among which its energy security prevails. Yet, Hungary’s differing position on the war from that of the EU and the V4 by being pro-Russian as a result of being pro-Hungarian stems from its divergent views on security and foreign policy objectives. Although Hungary’s stance on the war has affected the V4 cooperation adversely at the beginning, as there is no clear end to the Russia-Ukraine war soon, Hungary’s partners shifted their attitudes to focus on their shared interests inside the V4 bloc rather than on what separates them.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Hungary, Visegrad Group, Russia-Ukraine war, foreign policy, European Union.

Kaynakça

• Adam, Zoltan (2023). “Politicizing war: Viktor Orbán’s right-wing authoritarian populist regime and the Russian invasion of Ukraine”, in The Impacts of the Russian Invasion of Ukraine on Right-Wing Populism in Europe, Gilles Ivaldi and Emilia Zankina (Eds.), 168-185, Brussels: European Center for Populism Studies.
• Adam, Zoltan and Ivan Csaba (2022). “Populism unrestrained: Policy responses of the Orbán regime to the pandemic in 2020–2021”. European Policy Analysis 8: 277-296.
• Akgul Durakcay, Fulya (2023). “The European Union’s policies to protect the rule of law in the case of democratic backsliding in Hungary”. Akademik Hassasiyetler 10(22): 01-28.
• AP News (2023). “Poland to be 1st NATO member to give Ukraine fighter jets”. Retrieved from https://apnews.com/article/ukraine-poland-russia-war-jets-migs 6d843ccbd50fef5f96091a5bff8f3e01/. Accessed: 13.08.2023.
• Arato, Krisztina and Boglarka Koller (2018). “Hungary in the Visegrad Group”, in Central and Eastern Europe in the EU: Challenges and Perspectives under Crisis Conditions, Christian Schweiger and Anna Visvizi (Eds.), 90-105, London and New York: Routledge.
• Baczynska, Gabriela and John Chalmers (2020). “Hungary’s Orban says EU should reverse Russia sanctions, not push Cyprus on Belarus”. Reuters. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/article/us-hungary-orban-russia-belarus-idUSKCN26G2IU/. Accessed: 31.07.2023.
• Bauerova, Helena (2018). “Migration policy of the V4 in the context of Migration Crisis”. Politics in Central Europe 14(2): 99-120.
• Bayer, Lili (2022). “Hungary refuses to allow weapons transit to Ukraine”. Politico. Retrieved from https://www.politico.eu/article/hungary-foreign-minister-peter-szijjarto-weapon-transit-ukraine/. Accessed: 15.08.2023.
• BBC News (2014). “Hungary PM Orban condemns EU sanctions on Russia”. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-28801353/. Accessed: 28.07.2023.
• Boyse, Matt (2023). “Visegrad 4 is limping along”. GIS. Retrieved from https:// www.gisreportsonline.com/r/visegrad-4-political/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Brader, Adam (2023). “Orbán: Hungary must stay out of the war”. Hungarian Conservative. Retrieved from https://www.hungarianconservative.com/articles/current/orban_hungary_interview_sanctions_war_soros/. Accessed: 20.08.2023.
• Cabada, Ladislav and Sarka Waisova (2018). “The Visegrad Group as an ambitious actor of (Central-)European foreign and security policy”. Politics in Central Europe 4(2): 9-20.
• Canveren, Onder and Fulya Akgul Durakcay (2017). “The analysis of the Hungarian government’s discourse towards the migrant crisis: A combination of securitization and euroscepticism”. Yönetim ve Ekonomi 24(3): 857-876.
• Csernus, Dóra (2023). Country Report Hungary – Energy Without Russia: The Consequences of the Ukraine war and the EU Sanctions on the Energy Sector in Europe. Budapest: Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung. Debiec, Krzystof (2022). “Slovakia: strategic dilemmas after the Russian invasion of Ukraine”. OSW Centre for Eastern Studies. Retrieved from https:// www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/osw-commentary/2022-05-10/slovakia-strategic-dilemmas-after-russian-invasion-ukraine/. Accessed: 10.08.2023.
• Dunai, Marton (2023). “Hungarians in Ukraine turn against Viktor Orbán”. Financial Times. Retrieved from https://www.ft.com/content/88d6ffab-5cab- 4db1-bf43-d44a7eac00c8. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Dyduch, Joanna and Artur Skorek (2020). “Go South! Southern dimension of the V4 states’ energy policy strategies – An assessment of viability and prospects”. Energy Policy 140: 1-11.
• Euractiv (2017). “Hungary wants EU to review Ukraine ties over minority languages law”. Retrieved from https://www.euractiv.com/section/languages-culture/news/hungary-wants-eu-to-review-ukraine-ties-over-minority-languages-law/. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Euronews (2022a). “Ukraine war: Poland’s Kaczynski surprises by slamming Hungarian ally Orban on Ukraine”. Retrieved from https://www.euronews. com/2022/04/08/ukraine-war-poland-s-kaczynski-surprises-by-slamming-hungarian-ally-orban-on-ukraine/. Accessed: 22.08.2023.
• Euronews (2022b). “Ukraine war: Poland and Czech Republic refuse meeting over Hungary’s stance on Russia”. Retrieved from https://www.euronews. com/2022/03/29/visegrad-defence-ministers-meeting-cancelled-over-hungary-s-stance-on-russia/. Accessed: 21.08.2023.
• European Parliament (2019). “Situation of the Hungarian minority in Ukraine”. Parliamentary question – E-002218/2019. Retrieved from https://www.europarl. europa.eu/doceo/document/E-9-2019-002218_EN.html. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Feledy, Botond (2015). “Hungarian foreign policy and the crisis in Ukraine”, in Diverging Voices, Converging Policies: The Visegrad States’ Reactions to the Russia-Ukraine Conflict, Jacek Kucharczyk and Grigorij Meseznikov (Eds.), 69-82, Warsaw: Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung.
• Gavin, Gabriel (2023). “Ukraine accuses Hungary of funding Russian war crimes with energy deals”. Politico. Retrieved from https://www.politico.eu/ article/hungary-ukraine-russia-gas-deal-urges-eu/. Accessed: 23.08.2023.
• Gencturk, Ahmet (2022). “Czech Republic slams Hungary for refusal to back sanctions on Russian energy”. Anadolu Agengy. Retrieved from https:// www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/czech-republic-slams-hungary-for-refusal-to-back-sanctions-on-russian-energy/2590836/. Accessed: 26.08.2023.
• Griessler, Christina (2018). “The V4 Countries’ foreign policy concerning the Western Balkans”. Politics in Central Europe 14(2): 141-164.
• Gyori, Boldizsar and Krisztina Than (2023). “Hungary PM criticized Ukraine, says no rush to ratify Sweden’s NATO bid”. Reuters. Retrieved from https:// www.reuters.com/world/europe/hungary-pm-criticizes-ukraine-says-no-rush-ratify-swedens-nato-bid-2023-09-25/. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Gyori, Lorant, Bulcsú Hunyadi, Attila Juhász and Péter Krekó (2015). “Domestic Political Context since 1989: Hungary, Russia, Ukraine”, in Diverging Voices, Converging Policies: The Visegrad States’ Reactions to the Russia-Ukraine Conflict, Jacek Kucharczyk and Grigorij Meseznikov (Eds.), 52-68, Warsaw: Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung.
• Herszenhorn, David M., Jacopo Barigazzi and Barbara Moens (2022). “After Orbán pipes up, Hungary skips Russian oil ban”. Politico. Retrieved from https:// www.politico.eu/article/orban-hungary-eu-oil-ban-exempt-euco/. Accessed: 23.08.2023.
• Higgins, Andrew (2022). “War in Ukraine prompts a political makeover in Poland”. NY Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/18/world/ europe/poland-jaroslaw-kaczynski-ukraine-eu.html/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Holesch, Adam and Anna Kyriazi (2022). “Democratic backsliding in the European Union: the role of the Hungarian-Polish coalition”. East European Politics 38(1): 1-20.
• Hungarian Central Statistical Office. “6.1.1.2. Primary energy balance”. Retrieved from https://www.ksh.hu/stadat_files/ene/en/ene0002.html. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Hungary Today (2022). “PM Orbán: Hungary must stay out of conflict”. Retrieved from https://hungarytoday.hu/orban-ukraine-conflict-hungary-ukrainian-war/. Accessed: 02.08.2023.
• Huseyinzade, Huseyingulu (2022). “Polish president criticizes Hungary’s policy on Russian attack on Ukraine”. Anadolu Agency. Retrieved from https://www. aa.com.tr/en/europe/polish-president-criticizes-hungary-s-policy-on-russian-attack-on-ukraine/2547937. Accessed: 20.08.2023.
• Jack, Victor (2022). “Poland’s Kaczyński slams Orbán for refusing to condemn Bucha killings”. Politico. Retrieved from https://www.politico.eu/article/ poland-kaczynski-slams-hungary-orban-for-refusing-to-condemn-bucha-killings/. Accessed: 22.08.2023.
• Janicek, Karel (2023). “Slovakia, after Poland, agrees to give Ukraine Soviet jets”. AP News. Retrieved from https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-war-mig-slovakia-jets-4d72dfd433950a23bea7655870ce0e24/. Accessed: 10.08.2023.
• Kolozsi, Adam (2022). “The War in Ukraine Drives a Wedge Between Poland and Hungary”. Visegrad Insight. Retrieved from https://visegradinsight.eu/ the-war-in-ukraine-drives-a-wedge-between-poland-and-hungary/. Accessed: 15.08.2023.
• Kratochvil, Petr and Vera Rihackova (2015). “Domestic political context since 1989: Russia as a dividing element in Czech society”, in Diverging Voices, Converging Policies: The Visegrad States’ Reactions to the Russia-Ukraine Conflict, Jacek Kucharczyk and Grigorij Meseznikov (Eds.), 14-24, Warsaw: Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung.
• Kusumawardani, Damar and Radityo Dharmaputra (2014). “Hypocritical policy Viktor Orbán in Crimean annexation 2014”. Proceedings of Airlangga Conference on International Relations (ACIR 2018) - Politics, Economy, and Security in Changing Indo-Pacific Region, 455-461.
• Liboreiro, Jorge (2022). “Ukraine war: Hungary blocks €18 billion in aid for Kyiv and deepens rift with EU”. Euronews. Retrieved from https://www. euronews.com/my-europe/2022/12/06/eu-ministers-delay-key-votes-on-tax-deal-and-ukraine-aid-over-hungary-impasse. Accessed: 07.08.2023.
• Lopatka, Jan (2022). “Czechs, Poles criticise Hungary’s Orban amid divisions over Ukraine war”. Reuters. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/article/ ukraine-crisis-easteurope-idAFL1N32K160. Accessed: 23.08.2023.
• Madlovics, Balint and Balint Magyar (2023). “Kacynski’s Poland and Orbán’s Hungary: Different forms of autocracy with common right-wing frames in the EU”. Journal of Right-Wing Studies 1(1): 1-36.
• Meseznikov, Grigorij and Zora Butorova (2022). Russia’s war against Ukraine: A view from Slovakia. Bratislava: Konrad Adaeur Stiftung.
• Ministry of Defence of the Slovak Republic (2021a). “Security Strategy of the Slovak Republic”. Retrieved from https://www.mzv.sk/ documents/30297/4638226/security-strategy-of-the-slovak-republic.pdf. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Ministry of Defence of the Slovak Republic (2021b). “Defence strategy of the Slovak Republic”. Retrieved from https://www.mosr.sk/data/files/4291_ defence-strategy-of-the-slovak-republic-2021.pdf/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade of Hungary (2014). “Report of the Hungarian presidency of the Visegrad Group July 2013 – June 2014”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/annual-reports/. Accessed: 06.07.2023.
• Ministry of National Development (2012). “National Energy Strategy 2030”. Retrieved from https://2010-2014.kormany.hu/download/a/b7/70000/ Hungarian%20Energy%20Strategy%202030%20Summary.pdf/. Accessed: 28.07.2023.
• Moens, Barbara, Jacopo Barigazzi and Leonie Kijewski (2023). “New sanctions against Russia stuck in limbo over Greek-Hungarian protest”. Politico. Retrieved from https://www.politico.eu/article/new-sanctions-against-russia-stuck-limbo-greece-hungary-protest-ukraine-war/. Accessed: 19.08.2023.
• MTI-Hungary Today (2023). “Hungarians reject energy sanctions in national consultation”. Retrieved from https://hungarytoday.hu/hungarians-reject-energy-sanctions-in-national-consultation/. Accessed: 25.08.2023.
• Orbán, Viktor [@PM_ViktorOrban] (2022a). “What is the European interest? To switch Russian energy dependence to US energy dependence? No. We need energy independence instead.” Twitter. Retrieved from https://twitter.com/PM_ ViktorOrban/status/1580871667785420801/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Orbán, Viktor [@PM_ViktorOrban] (2022b). “It is no help to Ukraine if the European economy goes bankrupt. We are threatened by years of recession due to a primitive and ineffective sanctions regime. A hike in European unemployment will not help. We must aid Ukraine in a way that does not lead to our own defeat.” Twitter. Retrieved from https://twitter.com/PM_ViktorOrban/ status/1580469950774644736/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Orbán, Viktor [@PM_ViktorOrban] (2022c). “Let me be crystal clear: we are ready to support #Ukraine financially. In fact, we are the first EU country to pledge funds to the 18bn package requested by Ukraine. But we will do this on a bilateral basis. The #EU is not a debt community.” Twitter. Retrieved from https://twitter.com/PM_ViktorOrban/status/1596169303329587201/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Orbán, Viktor [@PM_ViktorOrban] (2023). “Instead of shipping weapons to Ukraine we should finally bring peace. Hungary stands firmly on the side of #peace at the #NATOSummitVilnius!” Twitter. Retrieved from https://twitter. com/PM_ViktorOrban/status/1678788530200354816/. Accessed: 25.08.2023.
• PBS News (2022). “How the Czech Republic is supporting Ukraine’s fight against Russia”. Retrieved from https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/how-the-czech-republic-is-supporting-ukraines-fight-against-russia/. Accessed: 10.08.2023.
• Racz, Andras (2014). “The Visegrad Cooperation: Central Europe divided over Russia”, L’Europe en Formation 4(374): 61-76.
• RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty (2022). “Orban imposes new state of emergency in Hungary, saying Ukraine war poses ‘constant danger’”. Retrieved from https://www.rferl.org/a/hungary-orban-state-of-emergency-ukraine-war-russia/31866003.html/. Accessed: 03.08.2023.
• Rettman, Andrew (2020). “Poland calls for ‘NATO’ readiness on Russia”. Euobserver. Retrieved from https://euobserver.com/rule-of-law/147271/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• Reuters (2022). “Hungary to stay out of Ukraine-Russia conflict, Orban says”. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/hungary-stay-out-ukraine-russia-conflict-orban-says-2022-02-27/. Accessed: 15.08.2023.
• Reuters (2023). “Czechs call Russia a threat, China a systemic challenge in new security strategy”. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/world/czechs-call-russia-threat-china-systemic-challenge-new-security-strategy-2023-06-28/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.
• RT News (2014). “Canceled language law in Ukraine sparks concern among Russian and EU diplomats”. Retrieved from https://www.rt.com/news/minority-language-law-ukraine-035/. Accessed: 21.10.2023. Sadecki, Andrzej (2014). In a State of Necessity: How Has Orban Changes Hungary. Warsaw: Centre for Eastern Studies.
• Saidel, Peter (2022). “The Russia-Ukraine War: May 11, 2022”. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/russia-ukraine-latest-news-2022-05-11/card/czech-republic-takes-further-steps-to-support-ukraine-YU9NwDZ1L1hQRtKge360-YU9NwDZ1L1hQRtKge360/. Accessed: 05.08.2023.
• Simon, Zoltan (2023). “How EU is withholding funding to try to rein in Hungary, Poland”. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost. com/business/how-eu-is-withholding-funding-to-try-to-rein-in-hungary-poland/2022/12/30/ba3641fc-8818-11ed-b5ac-411280b122ef_story.html/. Accessed: 06.08.2023.
• State Statistics Committee of Ukraine (2001). “All-Ukrainian population census 2001”. Retrieved from http://2001.ukrcensus.gov.ua/eng/regions/reg_zakar/. Accessed: 21.10.2023.
• Strnad, Vladislav (2022). “Les enfants terribles de l’Europe? The ‘Sovereigntist’ Role of the Visegrád Group in the context of the migration crisis”. Europe-Asia Studies 74(1): 72-100.
• Szakacs, Gergely (2022). “Hungary will not veto EU sanction on Russia – Orban”. Reuters. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/hungary-will-not-veto-eu-sanctions-russia-orban-2022-03-03/. Accessed: 10.08.2023.
• Than, Krisztina (2022). “Hungary will stay out of Ukraine war, PM Orban tells rally”. Reuters. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ tens-thousands-rally-support-hungarys-orban-election-nears-2022-03-15/. Accessed: 16.08.2023.
• Tidey, Alice and Agence France Press (2022). “Hungary agrees deal and lifts veto on €18bn EU aid package for Ukraine”. Euronews. Retrieved from https:// www.euronews.com/my-europe/2022/12/13/hungary-lifts-vetoes-on-ukraine-aid-and-corporate-tax-to-lower-frozen-eu-funds. Accessed: 16.08.2023.
• Tilles, Daniel (2022). “‘The paths of Poland and Hungary have diverged,’ says Polish PM”. Notes From Poland. Retrieved from https://notesfrompoland. com/2022/07/30/the-paths-of-poland-and-hungary-have-diverged-says-polish-pm/. Accessed: 21.08.2023.
• Toro, Csaba, Eamon Butler and Karoly Gruber (2014). “Visegrád: The evolving pattern of coordination and partnership after EU enlargement”. Europe-Asia Studies 66(3): 364-393.
• Visegrad Group (1991). “Visegrad Declaration 1991 - Declaration on Cooperation between the Czech and Slovak Federal Republic, the Republic of Poland and the Republic of Hungary in striving for European integration”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/visegrad-declarations/visegrad-declaration-110412-2/. Accessed: 01.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2004a). “Visegrad Declaration 2004 - Declaration of Prime Ministers of the Czech Republic, the Republic of Hungary, the Republic of Poland and the Slovak Republic on cooperation of the Visegrad Group countries after their accession to the European Union”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/visegrad-declarations/visegrad-declaration-110412-1/. Accessed: 01.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2004b). “Guidelines on the future areas of Visegrad cooperation”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/cooperation/ guidelines-on-the-future-110412/. Accessed: 01.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2013). “Hungarian Presidency in the Visegrad Group (2013– 2014)”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/presidency-programs/20132014-hungarian#_Main%20Priorities/. Accessed: 05.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2014a). “Budapest Declaration of the Visegrad Group Heads of Government on the New Opening in V4 Defence Cooperation”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/calendar/2014/budapest-declaration-of/. Accessed: 06.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2014b). “Statement of the Prime Ministers of the Visegrad Countries on Ukraine”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/ calendar/2014/statement-of-the-prime/. Accessed: 20.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2015). “Joint Statement of the Heads of Government of the Visegrad Group Countries”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/ calendar/2015/joint-statement-of-the-150904/. Accessed: 10.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2017). “2017-2018 Hungarian Presidency – V4 Connects”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/20172018- hungarian/. Accessed: 13.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2018). “Stronger Together – Joint Statement of the Prime Ministers of the Visegrad Group”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup. eu/documents/official-statements/. Accessed: 13.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2021). “V4 Recharging Europe – Programme of the Presidency”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/ presidency-programs/. Accessed: 14.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2022a). “Conclusions of the Meeting of European Affairs Committees of V4 Parliaments”. Retrieved from https://www.visegradgroup.eu/ documents/official-statements/. Accessed: 15.07.2023.
• Visegrad Group (2022b). “Joint Communiqué on Providing Joint V4 Assistance to Refugees from Ukraine 8 March 2022”. Retrieved from https://www. visegradgroup.eu/documents/official-statements/. Accessed: 15.07.2023.
• Visnovitz, Péter and Erin Kristin Jenne (2021). “Populist argumentation in foreign policy: the case of Hungary under Viktor Orbán, 2010–2020”. Comparative European Politics 19: 683-702.
• Visnovsky, Radovan (2020). “Visegrad Group and Relations with Russia”. VestnikRUDN. InternationalRelations 20(2): 347-355.
• Zachova, Aneta (2022). “Prague pressures Budapest to change its Russia stance”. Euractiv. Retrieved from https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/ short_news/prague-pressures-budapest-to-change-its-russia-stance/. Accessed: 24.08.2023.
• Zgut-Przybylska, Edit (2023). “Visegrad shaken to its core, Hungary in isolation”. Heinrich Böll Stiftung. Retrieved from https://cz.boell.org/en/2023/01/09/ visegrad-shaken-its-core-hungary-isolation/. Accessed: 28.08.2023.