Paul Brass and Criticism on the Conception of Ethnic Nationalism

Yıl 2018, Cilt: 20 Sayı: 35, 27 - 35, 28.12.2018

Ömer Fuad Kahraman

Öz

Paul Brass defines nationalism as a product of
modernism and does not see it as inevitable and compulsory. In other words, it
does not advocate that all the communities are nations or they’ll be achieve it
in the future. As so, Brass tries to answer a question which roots from there:
why and how did the nations come out? In order to answer this question, he
focuses his observations into historical experiences of countries in different
continents such as Europe, Africa and America, while he gives detailed
information especially on Asia. Brass claims that the nationalization process
is managed by elites. The elites transform their societies and groups of people
around their own interests while at the same time transforming these groups
into ethnic communities and then nations. However, it does not say that the
societies that once turned into a nation will no longer turn into a community.
In this study, the sub-headings of this distinction (being a nation and an
ethnic group) will be evaluated and crticized.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Nation, Paul Brass, Politicalization, Ethnicity, Ethnic Identitiy

Paul Brass ve Seçkinci Etnik Milliyetçilik Anlayışına Eleştiriler

Öz

Paul Brass milliyetçiliği modernizmin bir ürünü olarak
görmekle birlikte onu kaçınılmaz ve mecburi görmemektedir. Başka bir ifadeyle
her topluluğun millet olduğu veya ilerde millet olacağı sonucunu savunmaz.
Bundan olarak, öyleyse, ortaya çıkan bir soruyu çalışmalarında cevaplamaya
çalıştığı görülür: milletler neden ve nasıl ortaya çıkmıştır? Bu sorunun
cevaplanabilmesi için gözlemlerini Avrupa, Afrika ve Amerika gibi farklı kıtadaki
ülkelerin tarihi tecrübelerine çevirirken özellikle Güney Asya üzerinde detaylı
bilgiler aktarır. Gözlemlerini, millet olma sürecinin bir insan topluluğunun
kültürel farklılıklarla kendi etnik özbilincine varmasının ardından siyasal
talepler çerçevesinde şekillenmesine bağlayarak tamamlar. Brass’a göre bu
sürecin tamamı toplumda hâkim olan seçkinler (elitler) tarafından
yönetilmektedir. Seçkinler, toplumları ve insan gruplarını kendi çıkarları
etrafında şekillendirirken aynı zamanda bu grupları da önce etnik topluluklara,
sonra milletlere dönüştürürler. Ancak Brass bir kez millete dönüşen toplumların
artık tekrar etnik topluluğa dönüşmeyeceğini de söylemez, tarih boyunca farklı
milletler farklı zamanlarda ileri ve geri hareket eder gibi etnik grup-millet
olma süreçlerinden geçmiştir. Çalışma boyunca bu etnik grup olma - millet olma
ayrımından hareket edilecek ve bu ayrımın alt başlıkları değerlendirilecektir. 

Anahtar Kelimeler

: Millet, Paul Brass, Siyasallaşma, Etnik, Etnik Kimlik

Kaynakça

• Barth, Fredrik (1969) Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: The Social Organization of Culture Difference, Little & Brown Co. Boston.
• Brass, Paul (2010) Introduction, (ed.) Paul Brass, içinde Routledge Handbook of South Asian Politics: India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Nepal. Routledge Publication, Taylor and Francis Group, NY, pp. 1-24.
• Brass, Paul (1991) Ethnicity and Nationalism: Theory and Comparison, SAGE Publication, India.
• Brown, Lisa ve Johnson, Susan D. (1999) Ethnic Consciousness and Its Relationship to Conservatism and Blame Among African Americans, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 1999, 29, 12, pp. 2465-2480.
• Brubaker, Rogers (2004) Ethnicity without Groups, Harvard University Press, USA.
• Brubaker, Rogers (2013) Language, Religion and the Politics of Difference, Journal of the Association for the Study of Ethnicity and Nationalism, Nations and Nationalism 19 (1) p. 1-20.
• Brunet-Jailly, Emmanuel (2017) Languages, Nation and States, Border and Borderlands: A Critical Assessment, (ed.)Tomasz Kamusella, Motoki Nomachi and
• Catherine Gibson, Central Europe Through the Lens of Language and Politics: On the Sample Maps from the Atlas of Language Politics in Modern Central Europe, Slavic-Eurisian Research Center, p. 9-27.
• Burki, Shahid Javed (2010) Pakistan’s politics and its economy, (ed.) Paul Brass, içinde Routledge Handbook of South Asian Politics: India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Nepal. Routledge Publication, Taylor and Francis Group, NY, pp. 83-98.
• Diamond, Larry Jay (1994) Toward Democratic Consolidation, Journal of Democracy, Volume 5, Number 3, July 1994, pp. 4-17.
• Dorian, Nancy, C. (1999) Linguistic and Ethnographic Fieldwork, , içinde (ed) Joshua A. Fishman, Handbook of Language and Ethnic Identity, Oxford University Press, NY, p. 25-41.
• Gellner, Ernest. (1992) Uluslar ve Ulusçuluk, İnsan Yayınları, İstanbul.
• Govers, Cora ve Vermeulen, Hans (1997) From Political Mobilization to the Politics of Consciousness (ed.) Cora Govers ve Hans Vermeulen, içinde The Politics of
• Ethnic Consciousness, Palgrave Macmillan Press, pp. 1-31.
• Govers, Cora ve Vermeulen, Hans (1997) The Politics of Ethnic Consciousness, Palgrave Macmillian Press, NY.
• Gusfield, J. R. (1967). Tradition and Modernity: Misplaced Polarities in the Study of Social Change. American Journal of Sociology, 72(4), pp. 351–362.
• Hasenclever, A., ve Rittberger, V. (2000). Does Religion Make a Difference? Theoretical Approaches to the Impact of Faith on Political Conflict. Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 29(3), pp. 641–674.
• Kamusella, Tomasz (2017) Language in Central Europe’s History and Politics: From the Rule of cuius regio, eius religio to the National Principle of cuius regio, eius lingua? (ed.)Tomasz Kamusella, Motoki Nomachi and Catherine Gibson, Central Europe Through the Lens of Language and Politics: On the Sample Maps from the Atlas of Language Politics in Modern Central Europe, Slavic-Eurisian Research Center, p. 35-55.
• Kappus, Elke-Nicole (1997) Changing History: Ethnic Identity Management in Trieste, (ed.) Cora Govers ve Hans Vermeulen, içinde The Politics of Ethnic Consciousness, Palgrave Macmillan Press, pp. 90-121.
• Kertzel, David I. ve Arel, Dominique (2002) Census, Identity Formation, and the Struggle for Political Power, (ed.) David I. Kertzel and Arel Dominique, Census and Identitiy: The Politics of Race, Ethnicity and Language in National Censuses, Cambridge University Press, NY, p. 1-27.
• Kurien, Prema (2001) Religion, ethnicity and politics: Hindu and Muslim Indian immigrants in the United States, Ethnic and Racial Studies, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 24:2, Routledge, p. 263-293.
• Lachmann, Richard (2000) Capitalists in Spite of Themselves: Elite Conflict and Economic Transitions in Early Modern Europe, Oxford University Press, NY.
• Lentz, Carola (1997) Creating Ethnic Identities in North-Western Ghana, (ed.) Cora Govers ve Hans Vermeulen, içinde The Politics of Ethnic Consciousness, Palgrave Macmillan Press, pp. 31-90.
• Lovin, Robin (2002) Religion and Politics, , (ed.) Mary Hawkesworth ve Maurice Kogan içinde, Encylopedia of Government and Politics, Volume I, Routledge, pp. 521-534.
• Milgram, Stanley (1965) Some Conditions of Obedience and Disobedience to Authority, SAGE Publications, Human Relations, 18:1, p. 57-76.
• Nagel, Joane (1994) Constructing Ethnicity: Creating and Recreating Ethnic Identity and Culture: Social Problems, Vol. 41, No. 1, Special Issue on Immigration, Race, and Ethnicity in America (Feb), pp. 152-176.
• Neskryabina, Olga F. (2012) Ethnic Consciousness: Personal Sense and Signs of Ethnoidentity, Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences 7 (5) p. 951-957.
• Özkırımlı, Umut (2017). Milliyetçilik Kuramları: Eleştirel Bir Bakış, Doğu Batı Yayınları, Ankara.
• Peter Weinreich, Viera Bacova and Nathalie Rougier (2003) Basic Primordialism in Ethnic and National Identity, Peter Weinreich and Wendy Saunderson (ed.), Analysing Identity: Cross-cultural, Societal and Clinical Contexts, Routledge, NY.
• Safran, William (1999) Nationalism, içinde (ed) Joshua A. Fishman, Handbook of Language and Ethnic Identity, Oxford University Press, NY, p. 77-93.
• Smith, Anthony D. (1986) Ulusların Etnik Kökeni, Dost Kitabevi Yayınları, Aralık 2002.
• Talbot, Ian (2010) India and Pakistan, (ed.) Paul Brass, içinde Routledge Handbook of South Asian Politics: India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Nepal. Routledge Publication, Taylor and Francis Group, NY, pp. 27-40.
• Tyler, Tom R. ve Lind, E. Allan (2002) Understanding the Nature of Fraternalistic Deprivation: Does Group-based Deprivation Involve Fair Outcomes or Fair Treatment?, içinde (ed.) Walker, Iain ve Smith, Heather J., Relative Deprivation: Specification, Development, and Integration, Cambridge University Press, UK, p. 44-68.
• Walker, Iain ve Smith, Heather J. (2002) Relative Deprivation: Specification, Development, and Integration, Cambridge University Press, UK.
• Warminska, Katarzyna (1997) Polish Tartars: Ethnic Ideology and State Policy, (ed.) Cora Govers ve Hans Vermeulen, içinde The Politics of Ethnic Consciousness, Palgrave Macmillan Press, pp. 343-367.
• Weatherford, Jack (1994) Vahşiler, Barbarlar ve Uygarlık, (Savages and Civilization: Who will Survive’dan çev. Şen Süer) Versus Kitap Yayıncılık, İstanbul.