Editöre Mektuba Cevap: Literatür Taraması ve Çalışma Katkılarına İlişkin Açıklamalar

Year 2025, Volume: 10 Issue: 1, 117 - 118, 04.02.2025

Abdullah Uçar , Yasemin Denizli , Mahmut Talha Uçar , Muhammet Yunus Tunca

Abstract

Dear Editor,

We would like to express our gratitude for forwarding the letter regarding our article to the Editor. This has provided us with the opportunity to address the reasons for not citing the study by Öztürk et al. In the following section, we present our responses to the points raised in their letter:

The data collection period for the study by Öztürk et al. was between June 1, 2022, and July 15, 2022. The submission and acceptance dates of the article are 15 August 2022 and 28 October 2022, respectively (1). In our study, the literature review and data collection phase ended on 2 August 2022 at 17:30, after which the analysis phase began and was extended to include the 2022 dissertations. The analysis phase was not only a cross-sectional analysis, but software coding was done to create a real-time dynamic database architecture in which the findings would be automatically updated as new data were entered into the system. All entries and digital footprints in our database have log records to verify this timeline. Our preliminary analyses were presented as a conference paper at the 6th International Public Health Congress held the same year, and we subsequently included new theses published in 2022 as we completed advanced analyses in 2023 (2). Thus, the literature review for our study was conducted before the publication of Öztürk et al.’s article, which had not been released during our review phase. By its publication, our study had progressed to the analysis stage.

Keywords

Halk sağlığı, bilgi keşfi, tez, bibliyometrik analiz, metabilim

Response to the Letter to the Editor: Clarifications on Literature Review and Study Contributions

Abstract

Dear Editor,

We would like to express our gratitude for forwarding the letter regarding our article to the Editor. This has provided us with the opportunity to address the reasons for not citing the study by Öztürk et al. In the following section, we present our responses to the points raised in their letter:

The data collection period for the study by Öztürk et al. was between June 1, 2022, and July 15, 2022. The submission and acceptance dates of the article are 15 August 2022 and 28 October 2022, respectively (1). In our study, the literature review and data collection phase ended on 2 August 2022 at 17:30, after which the analysis phase began and was extended to include the 2022 dissertations. The analysis phase was not only a cross-sectional analysis, but software coding was done to create a real-time dynamic database architecture in which the findings would be automatically updated as new data were entered into the system. All entries and digital footprints in our database have log records to verify this timeline. Our preliminary analyses were presented as a conference paper at the 6th International Public Health Congress held the same year, and we subsequently included new theses published in 2022 as we completed advanced analyses in 2023 (2). Thus, the literature review for our study was conducted before the publication of Öztürk et al.’s article, which had not been released during our review phase. By its publication, our study had progressed to the analysis stage.

Keywords

Public health, knowledge discovery, dissertation, bibliometric analysis, metascience.

Ethical Statement

Etik kurul izni gerekmemektedir.

Supporting Institution

Yok

Thanks

Yok

References

• Yıldırım Öztürk EN, Yücel M, Uyar M. Bibliometric Analysis of Theses Made in Public Health and Registered in the National Thesis Center of the Council of Higher Education in Turkey. Hipokrat Tıp Dergisi / Hippocrates Medical Journal. 2022;2(3):15-22.
• Denizli Y, Uçar A, Uçar MT, Tunca MY. Bibliometric Analysis of Phd, Residency Dissertations and Master’s Theses in Public Health Departments in Türkiye Between 1970–2022. ESTÜDAM Halk Sağlığı Dergisi. 2024;9(2):142-53.
• Ucar A. ve Ark., 1970 - 2022 Yılları Arasında Türkı̇ye’de Halk Sağlığı Anabı̇lı̇m Dallarında Yapılmış Doktora, Uzmanlık ve Yüksek Lı̇sans Tezlerı̇nı̇n Bı̇blı̇yometrı̇k Analı̇zı̇, Sözlü Bildiri, 6. UHSK - Antalya, Aralık 2022.
• Nature at 150: evidence in pursuit of truth. Nature. 06 Nov 2019;575(7781):7-8.