Reviewer Evaluation Form

Evaluation Date:

Do you think this study has been fully or partially published before?*
YES
NO
Does the title adequately reflect the content of the article? *
YES
NO
Does the abstract adequately summarize the article?*
YES
NO
Is the purpose of the study clearly defined and explained? Does the study have a well-defined hypothesis?*
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Are the statistical methods used in the research specified? Are the statistical methods employed in the research appropriate for the research? *
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Are the findings/results of the research clearly stated? *
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Are there any finding/result that were not previously mentioned in the methods section?*
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
In the discussion, were the results/findings of the study compared with the relevant literature? *
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Are figures correctly and appropriately marked? *
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Are figure captions sufficient and standalone, and are they enough to be understood without having to refer to the main text?*
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Do the tables adequately explain the findings/results of the study?*
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Is the explanation of the abbreviations used in the tables given below the table? *
YES
NO
NOT APPLICABLE
Does the research offer new information (data, technique or idea) that is not available in the literature?*
YES
NO
Are the methods of data analysis adequate? *
YES
NO
The manuscript can be accepted for publication after revision. *
YES
NO
This manuscript should be reconsidered after revision. *
YES
NO

Suggestions to Author *


Comments to Editor


Recommendation *
Major Revision
Minor Revision
Reject
Accept